Galchenko Alexey Vladimirovich, Rizzo Gianluca, Baroni Luciana
Scientific Society for Vegetarian Nutrition-SSNV, Mestre, 30171 Venice, Italy.
Earth Philosophical Society "Melodia Vitae", Toronto, ON M9A4X9, Canada.
Foods. 2025 Mar 20;14(6):1062. doi: 10.3390/foods14061062.
In Eastern Europe, the number of vegetarians is growing, and the number of people adhering to Christian Lents is traditionally high. However, data on the nutritional value of plant-based diets in this part of the world are limited. The aim of this study was to compare the nutritional intakes of three groups with different plant-based patterns with that of omnivores in Russia, Moscow region. The nutrient intakes of 46 vegans, 49 lacto-ovo-vegetarians, 42 people who adhered to Orthodox Great Lent, and 48 omnivores were assessed. The food frequency questionnaire method was used for data collection and analysis. The differences in absolute and calorie adjusted nutrient intakes between the groups were analysed. Additionally, a pairwise comparison of the general plant-based group (combined of the vegan, lacto-ovo-vegetarian, and Great Lent samples) and the omnivorous groups was conducted. Vegan diet was the most favourable in micronutrient composition. The intake of many micronutrients increased when switching to a more plant-based diet from a more animal-based one. The opposite association was observed only for selenium and vitamins D and B. Fasting people consumed more iodine and n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids; however, after the calorie content was standardized, the omnivores caught up with them. The omnivores had the largest list of dietary inadequacies: they significantly more often than all other groups had inadequate intake of cholesterol (excessive), fibre, potassium, magnesium, iron, and vitamins B, B, B, and E (insufficient). Inadequate intake of polyunsaturated fatty acids, calcium, iodine, chromium, molybdenum, and zinc; or vitamins B, PP, H, B, and D was observed rather often in all the studied groups. Although, the vegan diet was richer in most micronutrients, plant products often contain substances that reduce the bioavailability of various nutrients, which can partially affect their status in the body, and, thus, may increase the need in them in vegetarians and fasters.
在东欧,素食者的数量在不断增加,并且长期坚持基督教斋戒的人数一直居高不下。然而,关于该地区以植物性饮食为主的营养价值数据有限。本研究的目的是比较俄罗斯莫斯科地区三种不同植物性饮食模式的人群与杂食者的营养摄入量。对46名纯素食者、49名蛋奶素食者、42名坚持东正教大斋期斋戒的人以及48名杂食者的营养摄入量进行了评估。采用食物频率问卷调查法进行数据收集与分析。分析了各组之间绝对营养素摄入量和能量调整后营养素摄入量的差异。此外,还对一般植物性饮食组(由纯素食者、蛋奶素食者和大斋期样本组合而成)和杂食组进行了两两比较。纯素饮食在微量营养素组成方面最为有利。从更多动物性饮食转向更多植物性饮食时,许多微量营养素的摄入量会增加。仅在硒、维生素D和维生素B方面观察到相反的关联。禁食者摄入更多的碘和n-3多不饱和脂肪酸;然而,在能量含量标准化后,杂食者与他们相当。杂食者饮食不足的清单最长:他们比所有其他组更频繁地出现胆固醇(过量)、纤维、钾、镁、铁以及维生素B、B、B和E(不足)摄入不足的情况。在所有研究组中,多不饱和脂肪酸、钙、碘、铬、钼和锌;或维生素B、PP、H、B和D摄入不足的情况相当常见。尽管纯素饮食富含大多数微量营养素,但植物性产品通常含有会降低各种营养素生物利用度的物质,这可能会部分影响它们在体内的状态,因此,可能会增加素食者和禁食者对这些营养素的需求。