Checkland Kath, Bramwell Donna, Hammond Jonathan, Bailey Simon, Warwick-Giles Lynsey
Division of Population Health, Health Services Research & Primary Care, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Centre for Health Services Studies, University of Kent, Canterbury, UK.
J Health Serv Res Policy. 2025 Apr 18:13558196251334571. doi: 10.1177/13558196251334571.
ObjectivesTo develop a model to support health systems in clarifying how they might target action to reduce health inequalities, and to use it to understand current policy on health inequalities in England.MethodsWe used the wider literature on the definitions of health inequalities to draw together a schematic model which attempts to link together the different conceptualisations of health inequalities present in the literature with potential sites of action that could be taken by local health systems. We then undertook a document analysis of the policy documents and programmes underlying the recent reorganisation of the NHS in England.ResultsThe need to tackle health inequalities is cited as one of the main rationales underlying the changes. However, there is a lack of clarity within the documents around: the type of inequality being addressed; the identification of the group(s) suffering from inequalities; and the ways in which the assumed ameliorative mechanisms will work in practice. The documents place considerable emphasis on the assumption that closer partnership working will address inequalities, although the mechanisms by which this will be achieved are not specified and previous research demonstrates how difficult this can be.ConclusionsThe aspiration to tackle health inequalities through newly constituted Integrated Care Systems and Boards is welcome. However, it is well known that the contribution that health care services can make to addressing inequalities is relatively limited. Greater clarity is required of policy and local strategy if efforts are to be appropriately targeted.
目标
开发一个模型,以支持卫生系统阐明如何将行动目标设定为减少健康不平等现象,并利用该模型了解英国当前关于健康不平等的政策。
方法
我们利用关于健康不平等定义的更广泛文献,构建了一个示意性模型,该模型试图将文献中存在的健康不平等的不同概念与地方卫生系统可能采取行动的潜在领域联系起来。然后,我们对英国国民保健制度(NHS)近期重组背后的政策文件和计划进行了文献分析。
结果
解决健康不平等的必要性被认为是这些变革的主要基本原理之一。然而,文件中在以下方面缺乏明确性:所解决的不平等类型;遭受不平等的群体的识别;以及假定的改善机制在实践中将如何发挥作用。文件相当强调这样一种假设,即更紧密的伙伴关系合作将解决不平等问题,尽管实现这一目标的机制并未明确说明,而且先前的研究表明这可能有多困难。
结论
通过新组建的综合医疗系统和委员会来解决健康不平等问题的愿望是值得欢迎的。然而,众所周知,医疗服务在解决不平等问题方面的贡献相对有限。如果要使努力目标明确,就需要在政策和地方战略方面更加清晰。