Frank S, Cosey D, Angevine J, Cardone L
Am J Community Psychol. 1985 Jun;13(3):269-87. doi: 10.1007/BF00914933.
Sixty-four counselors and 32 alternative school teachers in 13 grass-roots agencies reported on levels of participation, influence, and competence in making clinical and administrative decisions. The data supported predictions that (a) professionals would report greater decision-making opportunities and abilities than nonprofessionals, and (b) that workers in general would report higher levels of participation, influence, and competence in clinical than in administrative domains, and higher levels of competence than influence in both domains. However, regression analyses testing the effects of the decision-making variables on different aspects of job satisfaction did not support predicted interactions among participation, influence, and competence. Rather, decision-making involvements had positive effects and decision-making abilities had negative effects on worker morale. The discussion high-lights the need for further research to identify the underlying processes involved in the observed relationships.
来自13个基层机构的64名顾问和32名替代学校教师报告了他们在临床和行政决策中的参与程度、影响力和能力水平。数据支持了以下预测:(a)专业人员比非专业人员会报告更多的决策机会和能力;(b)总体而言,工作人员在临床领域的参与度、影响力和能力水平会高于行政领域,且在两个领域中能力水平高于影响力。然而,检验决策变量对工作满意度不同方面影响的回归分析并不支持参与、影响力和能力之间预测的相互作用。相反,决策参与对员工士气有积极影响,而决策能力对员工士气有负面影响。讨论强调了进一步研究以确定观察到的关系中所涉及的潜在过程的必要性。