Carnegie Elaine, Gray-Brunton Carol, Kennedy Catriona, Pow Janette, Willis Diane, Whittaker Anne
School of Health and Social Care, Edinburgh Napier University, Edinburgh, UK.
School of Nursing, Midwifery and Paramedic Practice, Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen, UK.
Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2025 Dec;21(1):2491857. doi: 10.1080/21645515.2025.2491857. Epub 2025 Apr 21.
The success of vaccination programs relies on acceptance of recommended vaccines by communities and individuals. There is a paucity of evidence regarding how young men with intellectual disabilities actively produce or receive inclusive and accessible HPV information. As part of a larger qualitative study, we explored how young men with mild-moderate intellectual disabilities contend with information on HPV and how they negotiated safer sex prior to the introduction of the Scottish schools-based gender-neutral HPV vaccination program in 2019. Objectives included identifying strategies for reaching young men with intellectual disabilities; identifying modes of communication that enable young men with intellectual disabilities to discuss HPV; exploring knowledge, awareness, relevance, and participant experiences of HPV vaccination; perceived barriers and facilitators toward vaccination behavior; perceptions of publicly available HPV information and formats. Working with institutions of further education to identify participants, 18 young men chose to participate. Three focus group discussions using activity-oriented questions were conducted. Regardless of ability, a series of activities enabled them to explore questions about their knowledge of HPV and any experience of the vaccination program. Communication aids included familiar objects and symbols from daily life breaking down barriers and power inequities. Data were analyzed drawing on critical discourse analysis. Designed and tailored communication interventions were effective in reaching this population group. Adopting a participatory activity-oriented approach and spending significant time looking at pictures and artifacts enabled young men with mild-moderate intellectual disabilities to discuss behavioral risks and consequences of HPV and to identify design factors for accessible health information.
疫苗接种计划的成功依赖于社区和个人对推荐疫苗的接受程度。关于患有智力残疾的年轻男性如何积极获取或接收全面且易于理解的人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)信息,相关证据匮乏。作为一项更大规模定性研究的一部分,我们探讨了患有轻度至中度智力残疾的年轻男性如何理解HPV信息,以及在2019年苏格兰基于学校的无性别歧视HPV疫苗接种计划推出之前,他们是如何协商安全性行为的。目标包括确定接触患有智力残疾的年轻男性的策略;确定能使患有智力残疾的年轻男性讨论HPV的沟通方式;探索HPV疫苗接种的知识、认知、相关性及参与者体验;找出影响疫苗接种行为的障碍和促进因素;了解对公开可用的HPV信息及其形式的看法。我们与继续教育机构合作确定参与者,18名年轻男性选择参与。我们进行了三场使用以活动为导向问题的焦点小组讨论。无论能力如何,一系列活动使他们能够探讨关于他们对HPV的了解以及疫苗接种计划的任何经历的问题。沟通辅助工具包括来自日常生活的熟悉物品和符号,打破了障碍和权力不平等。我们运用批判性话语分析对数据进行了分析。精心设计和量身定制的沟通干预措施有效地覆盖了这一人群。采用以参与活动为导向的方法并花费大量时间查看图片和人工制品,使患有轻度至中度智力残疾的年轻男性能够讨论HPV的行为风险和后果,并确定便于获取的健康信息的设计因素。