Westfall John M, Fernald Douglas H, Kamerow Douglas B
DARTNet Institute, Aurora, CO.
Department of Family Medicine, University of Colorado, Aurora, CO.
Fam Med. 2025 Apr;57(4):292-297. doi: 10.22454/FamMed.2025.462568. Epub 2025 Mar 7.
Family medicine has experienced wide variation in the proportion of allopathic medical students it attracts, ranging from a high of 16.8% to a low of 6.8%. We sought to measure the changes in specialty choice between the start of medical school and graduation.
We compared the specialty choice reported on the American Association of Medical Colleges annual allopathic Matriculating Student Questionnaire (MSQ) from 2014 to 2017 with the Graduation Questionnaire (GQ) from 2018 to 2021.
Among 55,635 students who completed both the MSQ and the GQ, more than 70% changed their specialty choice between matriculation and graduation. Just 45% of students who reported family medicine at matriculation chose family medicine at graduation. However, 70% of students entering family medicine at graduation had selected some other specialty at the start of medical school. This increase of more than 3,000 students who made their family medicine specialty choice during medical school represents a net gain of nearly 1,000 students entering family medicine over the 4 years.
Most allopathic medical students change their specialty choice during medical school. The historic concern about students being talked out of family medicine during medical school is still partially valid, yet the data reported here show that the majority of students entering family medicine at graduation had reported a different specialty when they entered medical school. While increasing family medicine recruitment into medical school is crucial, these data also show the critical importance of family medicine departments helping recruit and support medical students' family medicine choice during medical school.
在吸引的全科医学专业医学生比例方面,家庭医学领域存在很大差异,从高达16.8%到低至6.8%不等。我们试图衡量从医学院入学开始到毕业期间专业选择的变化。
我们将2014年至2017年美国医学院协会年度全科医学录取学生问卷(MSQ)中报告的专业选择与2018年至2021年的毕业问卷(GQ)进行了比较。
在同时完成MSQ和GQ的55,635名学生中,超过70%的学生在入学和毕业之间改变了他们的专业选择。入学时报告选择家庭医学的学生中,只有45%在毕业时选择了家庭医学。然而,毕业时进入家庭医学专业的学生中有70%在医学院入学开始时选择了其他专业。在医学院期间做出家庭医学专业选择的学生增加了3000多名,这意味着在这4年中进入家庭医学专业的学生净增加了近1000名。
大多数全科医学专业医学生在医学院期间会改变他们的专业选择。过去对医学院期间学生被劝离家庭医学专业的担忧仍然部分成立,但此处报告的数据表明,大多数毕业时进入家庭医学专业的学生在进入医学院时报告的是不同的专业。虽然增加医学院家庭医学专业的招生至关重要,但这些数据也表明了家庭医学部门在医学院期间帮助招募和支持医学生选择家庭医学专业的关键重要性。