Bazrafkan Aliasghar, Worral Hannah, Perdigon Cristhian, Oduor Peter G, Bandillo Nonoy, Flores Paulo
Department of Agricultural and Biosystems Engineering, North Dakota State University, Fargo, ND 58102, USA.
Department of Plant Science, North Dakota State University, Fargo, ND 58102, USA.
Sensors (Basel). 2025 Apr 12;25(8):2436. doi: 10.3390/s25082436.
Plant height is an important trait for evaluating plant lodging, drought, and stress. Standard measurement techniques are expensive, laborious, and error-prone. Although UAS-based sensors and digital aerial photogrammetry have been tested on plants with an erect growth habit, further study is needed in the application of these technologies to prostrate crops such as dry peas. This study has compared the performance of LiDAR, RGB, and multispectral sensors across different flight configurations (altitudes, speeds), and image overlaps over dry pea plots to identify the optimal setup for accurate plant height estimation. Data were assessed to determine the effect of sensor fusion on plant height accuracy using LiDAR's digital terrain model (DTM) as the base layer, and digital surface models (DSMs) generated from RGB and multispectral sensors. All sensors, particularly RGB, tended to underestimate plant height at higher flight altitudes. However, RMSE and MAE values showed no significant difference, indicating that higher flight altitudes can reduce data collection time and cost without sacrificing accuracy. Multispectral and LiDAR sensors were more sensitive to changes in flight speed than RGB sensors; However, RMSE and MAE values did not vary significantly across the tested speeds. Increased image overlap resulted in improved accuracy across all sensors. The Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test showed no significant difference between sensor fusion and individual sensors. Although LiDAR provided the highest accuracy of dry peas height estimation, it was not consistent across all canopy structures. Therefore, future research should focus on the integrating machine learning models with LiDAR to improve plant height estimation in dry peas.
株高是评估植物抗倒伏性、耐旱性和抗逆性的重要性状。标准测量技术成本高昂、 laborious且容易出错。尽管基于无人机的传感器和数字航空摄影测量已在具有直立生长习性的植物上进行了测试,但在将这些技术应用于诸如干豌豆等匍匐作物方面仍需要进一步研究。本研究比较了激光雷达、RGB和多光谱传感器在不同飞行配置(高度、速度)以及干豌豆地块上的图像重叠情况下的性能,以确定准确估算株高的最佳设置。使用激光雷达的数字地形模型(DTM)作为基础层,以及由RGB和多光谱传感器生成的数字表面模型(DSM),对数据进行评估以确定传感器融合对株高准确性的影响。所有传感器,尤其是RGB传感器,在较高飞行高度时往往会低估株高。然而,均方根误差(RMSE)和平均绝对误差(MAE)值没有显著差异,表明较高的飞行高度可以在不牺牲准确性的情况下减少数据采集时间和成本。多光谱和激光雷达传感器对飞行速度变化比RGB传感器更敏感;然而,在测试速度范围内,RMSE和MAE值没有显著变化。图像重叠增加导致所有传感器的准确性提高。威尔科克森-曼-惠特尼检验表明传感器融合与单个传感器之间没有显著差异。尽管激光雷达在干豌豆株高估计方面提供了最高的准确性,但在所有冠层结构中并不一致。因此,未来的研究应专注于将机器学习模型与激光雷达相结合,以提高干豌豆株高估计的准确性。