Thomas Siobhan D, Dempsey Maria, King Robert J, Murphy Mike
School of Applied Psychology, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland.
Transgend Health. 2025 Apr 11;10(2):126-149. doi: 10.1089/trgh.2022.0202. eCollection 2025 Apr.
A wide body of research explores the substantial issue of health care avoidance and delay (HAD) in the transgender population, and much focus has been given to the minority stress model in the exploration of associated factors. This review addresses gaps in the literature by investigating the cumulative evidence for association between HAD and minority stress, and by further examining the evidence for individual facets of minority stress. A secondary aim of this review is to examine how operationalization of HAD may impact our understanding of research findings.
Five databases were searched using inclusion and exclusion criteria. Four reviewers participated in screening at title and abstract, and full-text stages. Due to heterogeneity of methodology, findings were addressed through narrative synthesis.
Eighteen studies explored association between HAD and factors related to minority stress: Distal stressors in health care settings, general distal stressors, distal stressors related to structural and societal factors, and proximal stressors. Findings indicate evidence for association between HAD and many minority stress factors, most notably for a range of distal stressors in health care settings. However, results in some areas reveal sparse research on a wide range of variables and studies based on the same data sources. Mediation and moderation analyses are also underinvestigated in this area, while HAD measurement is characterized by binary operationalization.
This review underscores the importance of research that examines associations between HAD and minority stress factors in the transgender population and provides directions for future research to address gaps in current understanding.
大量研究探讨了跨性别群体中医疗保健回避与延误(HAD)这一重大问题,并且在探索相关因素时,很多研究聚焦于少数群体应激模型。本综述通过调查HAD与少数群体应激之间关联的累积证据,并进一步审视少数群体应激各个方面的证据,来填补文献中的空白。本综述的第二个目的是研究HAD的操作化如何影响我们对研究结果的理解。
使用纳入和排除标准检索了五个数据库。四名评审员参与了标题和摘要筛选以及全文筛选阶段。由于方法的异质性,研究结果通过叙述性综合进行阐述。
18项研究探讨了HAD与少数群体应激相关因素之间的关联:医疗保健环境中的远端应激源、一般远端应激源、与结构和社会因素相关的远端应激源以及近端应激源。研究结果表明,有证据支持HAD与许多少数群体应激因素之间存在关联,最显著的是医疗保健环境中的一系列远端应激源。然而,一些领域的结果显示,对于广泛变量以及基于相同数据源的研究,相关研究较少。该领域的中介和调节分析也未得到充分研究,而HAD测量的特点是二元操作化。
本综述强调了研究跨性别群体中HAD与少数群体应激因素之间关联的重要性,并为未来研究指明方向,以填补当前认识中的空白。