Jamieson Timothy, Gravelle Hugh, Santos Rita
Wolfson Institute of Population Health Queen Mary University of London, London E1 4NS, United Kingdom.
Centre for Health Economics, University of York, Alcuin block A, York YO10 5DD, United Kingdom.
Health Policy. 2025 Jul;157:105330. doi: 10.1016/j.healthpol.2025.105330. Epub 2025 Apr 24.
Attendances at emergency departments (EDs) by patients who could have been treated in primary care increase waiting times and costs in EDs and may reduce quality of care. This study examines whether the probability that a patient's ED attendance is avoidable is associated with their characteristics and the quality, staffing, and availability of their general practice, particularly its extended hours provision. We estimate ED attendance level linear probability and logistic regressions using data on 10.16 M attendances at 144 major EDs by patients aged 16 or over from 6668 English practices. We use two definitions of avoidable ED attendance: the NHS definition (non-urgent) and a new wider definition (clinically inappropriate). 9.3 % of attendances were avoidable according to the NHS definition and 21.8 % with our definition. The probability of avoidable attendance was lower for older, female patients, those living in more socioeconomically deprived or sparsely populated areas, or those closer to their practice than to the ED attended. Attendances from practices where a higher proportion of patients get same-day GP appointments, or were aware of early morning extended hours, were less likely to be avoidable. The probability that an ED attendance was clinically inappropriate was about 0.5 % smaller during weekends or evenings when the practice had extended hours but was not associated with the overall provision of extended hours by the practice.
那些本可在初级医疗保健机构接受治疗的患者前往急诊科就诊,会增加急诊科的候诊时间和成本,还可能降低医疗服务质量。本研究探讨患者前往急诊科就诊可避免的可能性是否与其特征以及全科医疗的质量、人员配备和可及性相关,特别是其延长营业时间的情况。我们利用来自6668家英格兰医疗机构的16岁及以上患者在144家主要急诊科的1016万次就诊数据,估计急诊科就诊水平的线性概率和逻辑回归。我们采用了两种可避免的急诊科就诊定义:英国国家医疗服务体系(NHS)的定义(非紧急情况)和一种新的更宽泛的定义(临床不适当情况)。根据NHS的定义,9.3%的就诊是可避免的;按照我们的定义,这一比例为21.8%。年龄较大的女性患者、生活在社会经济条件较差或人口稀少地区的患者,或者居住地距离其医疗机构比距离所就诊的急诊科更近的患者,可避免就诊的概率较低。来自患者同日预约全科医生比例较高或知晓清晨延长营业时间的医疗机构的就诊,可避免的可能性较小。当医疗机构延长营业时间时,在周末或晚上,急诊科就诊临床不适当的概率约低0.5%,但这与医疗机构总体延长营业时间无关。