Wong Lun Matthew, Ai Qi-Yong Hemis, Leung Ho Sang, So Tifffany Yuen-Tung, Hung Kuo Feng, Chan Yuet-Ting, King Ann Dorothy
Department of Imaging and Interventional Radiology, Prince of Wales Hospital, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, LG/F, Cancer Centre, Shatin, New Territory, HKSAR, China.
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, School of Clinical Medicine, The University of Hong Kong, HKSAR, China.
J Imaging Inform Med. 2025 May 6. doi: 10.1007/s10278-025-01520-8.
Wavelet decomposition (WD), widely used in radiomics, redistributes information among derived wavelet components when the input is rotated. This redistribution may alter predictions for the same lesion when scanned at different angles. Despite its potential significance, this vulnerability has frequently been overlooked in radiomic studies while its impact remains poorly understood. Therefore, this study aims to investigate how variations in lesion orientation affect both WD and non-WD radiomic feature values, and subsequently, model performance. We analyzed CT radiomics of primary non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Prior to feature extraction, we introduced random rotations ranging from 5° to 80° to the tumors. Their effects were quantified by evaluating the percentage difference ( ) between the rotated and unrotated feature values, and validated using Spearman's rank test. Additionally, radiomics models were trained to discriminate between three histological subtypes of NSCLC using the original features, and then tested on rotated inputs. The correlation between the model accuracies and the degree of rotation was again evaluated using Spearman's rank test. Four-hundred nineteen NSCLC patients (mean age: 68.1 ± 10.1, 289 men) were evaluated. Significant correlations between feature values and rotations (Spearman's correlation [CC] magnitude ≥ 0.1, p < .05) were found in 23.7% (176/744) of the WD and 0.5% (5/930) of the non-WD texture features. Significant association between performance and rotation was observed in WD-based models built to discriminate between NSCLC histological subtypes (CC = - 0.44, p < .001) but not in non-WD-based models (CC = 0.03, p = 0.07). Input lesion orientation affects radiomic feature values and model reproducibility. WD features exhibited significantly greater instability to orientation variations compared to non-WD features.
小波分解(WD)在放射组学中被广泛应用,当输入图像旋转时,它会在派生的小波分量之间重新分配信息。这种重新分配可能会改变同一病变在不同角度扫描时的预测结果。尽管其具有潜在的重要性,但在放射组学研究中,这种易受影响的特性经常被忽视,而其影响仍未得到充分理解。因此,本研究旨在探讨病变方向的变化如何影响WD和非WD放射组学特征值,以及随后的模型性能。我们分析了原发性非小细胞肺癌(NSCLC)的CT放射组学。在特征提取之前,我们对肿瘤引入了5°到80°的随机旋转。通过评估旋转和未旋转特征值之间的百分比差异( )来量化它们的影响,并使用Spearman秩检验进行验证。此外,使用原始特征训练放射组学模型以区分NSCLC的三种组织学亚型,然后在旋转输入上进行测试。再次使用Spearman秩检验评估模型准确性与旋转程度之间的相关性。对419例NSCLC患者(平均年龄:68.1±10.1,男性289例)进行了评估。在23.7%(176/744)的WD纹理特征和0.5%(5/930)的非WD纹理特征中发现特征值与旋转之间存在显著相关性(Spearman相关性[CC]幅度≥0.1,p<0.05)。在用于区分NSCLC组织学亚型的基于WD的模型中观察到性能与旋转之间存在显著关联(CC = -0.44,p<0.001),而在基于非WD的模型中未观察到(CC = 0.03,p = 0.07)。输入病变方向会影响放射组学特征值和模型的可重复性。与非WD特征相比,WD特征对方向变化表现出明显更大的不稳定性。