Bencharit Sompop, Quinn Barry, Sittoni-Pino Maria F, Arias-Herrera Santiago, Schick Simona-Georgiana, Rampf Sarah, Byrne Samantha, Shazib Muhammad A, Örtengren Ulf, Lam Walter Yu Hang, Liukkonen Mikko, Rice David, Nagasawa Masako, Ranauta Amitha, Zafar Sobia, Bágyi Kinga, Greany Thomas J, Luai Amirul Faiz, Øilo Marit, Rederiene Gitana, Stolberg Rebecca, Gül Gülsün, Tricio Jorge, Chau Reinhard Chun Wang, Pantea Mihaela, Mutluay Murat, Lingström Peter, Klein Ophir, Usta Sıla Nur, Suominen Liisa, Felszeghy Szabolcs
Workman School of Dental Medicine, High Point University, High Point, NC, United States.
School of Dentistry, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom.
Front Dent Med. 2025 Apr 24;6:1576646. doi: 10.3389/fdmed.2025.1576646. eCollection 2025.
Haptics-enhanced virtual reality (VR-haptics), a supplementary tool for traditional oral health training, shows promise in enhancing knowledge acquisition, manual dexterity, performance, and student well-being.
The aim of this study was to understand dental educators' perceptions and needs regarding the acceptability and application of VR-haptics in dental education, as well as to gather suggestions for system improvements.
In this global cross-sectional study, the VR-Haptic Thinkers Consortium used a 28-item online questionnaire distributed to 1,023 participants by August 1, 2024. The survey included questions on general demographics, multiple choice and five-point Likert-style questions, and open-ended questions.
A total of 378 responses were collected from 156 institutions. 57% of respondents had a dental doctorate degree and 59% had a PhD. VR-haptic trainers were used more often in preclinical training (94% of responses) than clinical training (46%). The three most common course types with VR-haptics incorporation were restorative, prosthodontic, and endodontic courses. Most respondents thought that the best approach to implementing VR-haptics is alongside phantom head training in the preclinical stage (58%). A third of the feedback on the challenges in VR-haptics utilization in dental training highlighted a need for further hardware and software development, while more than one-fourth cited economic issues in system acquisition and housing, and another one-fourth reported low acceptance of the technology among educators and students. The most mentioned enhancement requests for dental trainers were more diverse training scenarios (20%), improved software (19%) and hardware (19%) elements, and advancements in AI-based personalized training and monitoring (18%). Additionally, 10% of respondents suggested gamification features.
VR-haptic technology is constantly evolving and will likely become more and more accepted as an integral part of dental hand skill development to complement traditional preclinical training. Future research and development should emphasize transitioning from preclinical to clinical restorative, prosthodontic, endodontic, and implantology procedures as part of individualized education and patient care.
触觉增强虚拟现实(VR-触觉)作为传统口腔健康培训的辅助工具,在增强知识获取、手动灵活性、操作表现和学生幸福感方面显示出前景。
本研究的目的是了解牙科教育工作者对VR-触觉在牙科教育中的可接受性和应用的看法与需求,并收集系统改进建议。
在这项全球横断面研究中,VR触觉思考者联盟使用了一份包含28个条目的在线问卷,截至2024年8月1日已分发给1023名参与者。该调查包括一般人口统计学问题、多项选择题和五点李克特式问题以及开放式问题。
共从156个机构收集到378份回复。57%的受访者拥有牙科博士学位,59%拥有博士学位。VR-触觉训练器在临床前培训(94%的回复)中比临床培训(46%)中使用得更频繁。纳入VR-触觉的三种最常见课程类型是修复学、口腔修复学和牙髓病学课程。大多数受访者认为在临床前阶段实施VR-触觉的最佳方法是与仿真人头训练一起(58%)。关于牙科培训中VR-触觉使用挑战的三分之一反馈强调需要进一步进行硬件和软件开发,而超过四分之一提到系统购置和存放方面的经济问题,另有四分之一报告该技术在教育工作者和学生中的接受度较低。对牙科训练器最常提到的增强要求是更多样化的训练场景(20%)以及改进软件(19%)和硬件(19%)元素,还有基于人工智能的个性化训练和监测方面的进展(18%)。此外,10%的受访者建议加入游戏化功能。
VR-触觉技术在不断发展,可能会越来越被视为牙科手部技能发展不可或缺的一部分,以补充传统的临床前培训。未来的研发应强调从临床前向临床修复、口腔修复、牙髓病学和种植学程序的过渡,作为个性化教育和患者护理的一部分。