Whalin Laura, Barth Kerstin, Bertelsen Maja, Bokkers Eddie A M, Ferneborg Sabine, Haskell Marie J, Ivemeyer Silvia, Jensen Margit Bak, Johanssen Juni Rosann Engelien, Mejdell Cecilie M, Mughal Mikaela, Neave Heather W, Vaarst Mette, van Knegsel Ariette, van Zyl Coenraad L, Wegner Claire S, Johnsen Julie Føske
Department of Animal Health and Food Safety, Norwegian Veterinary Institute, 1431 Ås, Norway.
Institute of Organic Farming, Johann Heinrich von Thünen Institute, Federal Research Institute for Rural Areas, Forestry and Fisheries, 23847 Westerau, Germany.
J Dairy Sci. 2025 Jul;108(7):6550-6564. doi: 10.3168/jds.2024-26201. Epub 2025 May 8.
Prolonged cow-calf contact (CCC) is of growing importance to the dairy sector due to increasing societal interest, implementation of CCC on farms, and research efforts. Incorporating CCC into dairy systems may be a polarizing change for academics and farmers. However, by considering the challenges with curiosity, including those mutual to CCC and non-CCC systems, there may be an opportunity to collectively improve the management of dairy animals. The aim of this review was to describe current issues and constraints in CCC, propose opportunities to advance knowledge of CCC, and inspire forward-thinking questions for dairy systems. There are known challenges for CCC implementation, such as research reproducibility (e.g., suitable controls, validity types) and on-farm application (e.g., farmer perspectives, policies, and corporate standards). To facilitate practical solutions for farmers wanting to adopt CCC we need research describing the effects of CCC systems on animal health and behavior. Already researchers have begun to explore cow and calf performance and health, methods for decreasing stress at weaning and separation (e.g., duration of contact, gradual weaning), foster cows, and opportunities for positive animal welfare in CCC systems (e.g., affiliative and play behavior). However, because dairying takes place in a complex system, changes may affect different facets of the system's sustainability. We suggest that the development of CCC systems should happen in dialog with stakeholders. Cow-calf contact is an uncommon practice in dairy systems and exists in different contexts; thus, there are many questions to address before advice can be given to interested dairy stakeholders. Perhaps, these CCC-related questions are an invitation to contemplate how we want dairy systems to look like in 30 years.
由于社会关注度不断提高、农场实施牛犊与母牛长时间接触(CCC)以及研究工作的开展,CCC对乳制品行业的重要性日益凸显。将CCC纳入乳制品系统对学者和农民来说可能是一个两极分化的变化。然而,通过以好奇的心态考虑其中的挑战,包括CCC和非CCC系统共有的挑战,可能会有机会共同改善奶牛的管理。本综述的目的是描述CCC当前存在的问题和限制,提出推进CCC知识的机会,并激发对乳制品系统的前瞻性问题。CCC的实施存在一些已知的挑战,比如研究的可重复性(例如,合适的对照、有效性类型)和农场应用(例如,农民的观点、政策和企业标准)。为了帮助想要采用CCC的农民找到切实可行的解决方案,我们需要开展研究来描述CCC系统对动物健康和行为的影响。研究人员已经开始探索奶牛和牛犊的性能与健康、降低断奶和分离应激的方法(例如,接触时长、渐进式断奶)、代孕母牛以及CCC系统中动物福利改善的机会(例如,亲和行为和玩耍行为)。然而,由于乳制品生产发生在一个复杂的系统中,变化可能会影响该系统可持续性的不同方面。我们建议CCC系统的开发应该在与利益相关者的对话中进行。牛犊与母牛接触在乳制品系统中并不常见,且存在于不同的背景下;因此,在向感兴趣的乳制品利益相关者提供建议之前,有许多问题需要解决。也许,这些与CCC相关的问题是一个契机,促使我们思考30年后我们希望乳制品系统是什么样子。