Sambrook Laura, Balmer Anna, Tait Jackie, Ashley-Mudie Peter, McIntyre Jason C, Shetty Amrith, Nathan Rajan, Saini Pooja
Faculty of Health, Liverpool John Moores University, Liverpool, UK.
Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, Chester, UK.
BJPsych Open. 2025 May 14;11(3):e107. doi: 10.1192/bjo.2025.30.
More people than ever are receiving support for mental health crises, and instances of suicide continue to grow. Mental health funding has recently increased, focusing on improving services that provide an alternative to emergency departments, such as urgent helplines and crisis cafés. However, there is a lack of literature examining the efficacy of these services, despite research suggesting they may be associated with lower hospital admission rates.
We aimed to evaluate the perspectives of people with lived experience of accessing a variety of mental health crisis services in the UK.
One-to-one interviews were conducted with 25 individuals as part of a qualitative grounded theory analysis.
The following themes were identified as important for recovery: more than a diagnosis (a need for person-centred care); instilling hope for the future (access to creative spaces and community); and a safe space for recovery (out-of-hours crisis cafés). Many have credited crisis cafés with saving their lives and felt there should be increased funding provided for collaboration between the National Health Service (NHS) and the third sector. Participants highlighted the need for interim support for those awaiting therapy via the NHS and continuity of care as key areas for improvement.
NHS services are struggling to meet the mental health needs of the population, resulting in lengthy waiting times for therapy and an over-reliance on the third sector. While crisis cafés are currently provided at a low cost and appear to result in satisfaction, policymakers must ensure they receive adequate funding and do not become overburdened.
如今,接受心理健康危机支持的人数比以往任何时候都多,而自杀事件仍在不断增加。心理健康资金最近有所增加,重点是改善那些为急诊科提供替代方案的服务,如紧急求助热线和危机咖啡馆。然而,尽管有研究表明这些服务可能与较低的住院率相关,但缺乏对其效果进行研究的文献。
我们旨在评估在英国有过使用各种心理健康危机服务经历的人们的观点。
作为定性扎根理论分析的一部分,对25个人进行了一对一访谈。
确定了以下对康复至关重要的主题:不仅仅是诊断(需要以患者为中心的护理);为未来注入希望(获得创意空间和社区);以及一个安全的康复空间(非工作时间的危机咖啡馆)。许多人认为危机咖啡馆救了他们的命,并觉得应该增加资金,以促进国民保健制度(NHS)与第三部门之间的合作。参与者强调,为那些等待通过NHS接受治疗的人提供临时支持以及护理的连续性是需要改进的关键领域。
NHS服务难以满足民众的心理健康需求,导致治疗等待时间过长,且过度依赖第三部门。虽然危机咖啡馆目前成本较低且似乎能带来满意度,但政策制定者必须确保它们获得足够的资金,且不会不堪重负。