Nartker Makaela, Firestone Chaz, Egeth Howard, Phillips Ian
Department of Psychological & Brain Sciences, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, United States.
Department of Philosophy, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, United States.
Elife. 2025 May 19;13:RP100337. doi: 10.7554/eLife.100337.
The relation between attention, perception, and awareness is among the most fundamental problems in the science of the mind. One of the most striking and well-known phenomena bearing on this question is (IB). In IB, naive observers fail to report clearly visible stimuli when their attention is otherwise engaged-famously missing a gorilla parading before their eyes. IB carries tremendous significance, both as evidence that awareness requires attention and as a tool in seeking the neural correlates of consciousness. However, such implications rest on a notoriously biased measure: asking participants whether they noticed anything unusual (and interpreting negative answers as reflecting a complete lack of perception). Here, in the largest ever set of IB studies, we show that, as a group, inattentionally blind participants can successfully report the location, color, and shape of stimuli they deny noticing, demonstrating that perceptual information remains accessible in IB. By introducing absent trials, we further show that observers are collectively biased to report not noticing in IB-essentially 'playing it safe' in reporting their sensitivity. These data provide the strongest evidence to date of significant residual visual sensitivity in IB. They also challenge the use of inattentional blindness to argue that awareness requires attention.
注意力、感知与意识之间的关系是心智科学中最基本的问题之一。与这个问题相关的最显著且广为人知的现象之一是无意视盲(IB)。在无意视盲中,当朴素观察者的注意力被其他事情占据时,他们无法报告清晰可见的刺激——著名的例子是错过在他们眼前走过的一只大猩猩。无意视盲具有重大意义,既作为意识需要注意力的证据,也作为寻找意识神经关联物的一种工具。然而,这些含义基于一种众所周知的有偏差的测量方法:询问参与者是否注意到任何不寻常的事情(并将否定回答解释为反映完全没有感知)。在此,在有史以来最大规模的一组无意视盲研究中,我们表明,作为一个群体,无意视盲的参与者能够成功报告他们否认注意到的刺激的位置、颜色和形状,这表明在无意视盲中感知信息仍然是可获取的。通过引入无刺激试验,我们进一步表明观察者在无意视盲中集体倾向于报告未注意到——在报告他们的敏感度时基本上是“谨慎行事”。这些数据提供了迄今为止关于无意视盲中显著残余视觉敏感度的最有力证据。它们也对使用无意视盲来论证意识需要注意力提出了挑战。