Donadono Cesare, Tigani Domenico, Assenza Andrea, Censoni Davide, Pesce Francesco, Melucci Giuseppe
Department of Trauma and Orthopaedic Surgery, Maggiore Hospital, Largo Nigrisoli 2, 40133 Bologna, Italy.
Division of Renal Medicine, "Ospedale Isola Tiberina-Gemelli Isola", Via di Ponte Quattro Capi, 39, 00186 Rome, Italy.
J Pers Med. 2025 May 19;15(5):202. doi: 10.3390/jpm15050202.
Pertrochanteric fractures of the proximal femur present a common challenge for traumatologists, with intramedullary nailing emerging as the preferred treatment. Complication rates are around 20%, including screw jamming, refractures, implant breakage, or medial migration, with cut-out being the most common. A tip-apex distance (TAD) of >25 mm and incorrect cephalic screw position are predictive factors for cut-out. This study assesses outcomes using the Elos intramedullary nail, based on the experience of the Department of Orthopedics and Traumatology at Ospedale Maggiore in Bologna. We conducted a retrospective cohort study of 344 patients treated with the Elos intramedullary nail for pertrochanteric femoral fractures from 1 January 2017 to 31 December 2022. The Elos-Intrauma nail was implanted using the standard technique. Initial X-rays classified fractures according to the AO-OTA classification, and postoperative X-rays confirmed the cephalic screw's placement per Cleveland's regions. Patients were divided into two groups: optimal cephalic screw position (positions 5-8-9) and other positions. We evaluated TAD, calcar-referred TAD (CalTAD), and postoperative reduction quality using Chang's criteria. The incidence of cut-out and other complications were assessed in connection with these measurements. Among the 344 patients, 227 (65.9%) had the screw in positions 5-8-9, while 117 (34.1%) had it in other positions. The median TAD was 19.47 ± 6.26 mm (range 3.96-46.6), with TAD ≤ 25 mm in 265 patients (77%). The median CalTAD was 22.37 ± 5.65 mm (range 8.75-45.3), with CalTAD ≤ 25 mm in 231 patients (67.1%). According to Chang's criteria, 8 cases (2.3%) had poor reduction, 139 cases (40.4%) had acceptable reduction, and 197 cases (57.3%) had excellent reduction. Cut-out occurred in four cases (1.19%). Multivariate analysis revealed only poor reduction and TAD > 25 mm as independent predictors of cut-out ( < 0.05), while cephalic screw position, CalTAD, and fracture type did not impact cut-out incidence. This study indicates that optimal TAD and quality of reduction are crucial for minimizing cut-out risks. The Elos intramedullary nail shows favorable outcomes with a low cut-out incidence when these parameters are met. Emphasis should be placed on achieving a TAD ≤ 25 mm and excellent reduction quality to reduce complications.
股骨近端转子间骨折是创伤骨科医生面临的常见挑战,髓内钉固定已成为首选治疗方法。并发症发生率约为20%,包括螺钉卡压、再骨折、植入物断裂或向内侧移位,其中螺钉穿出是最常见的。尖顶距(TAD)>25 mm和股骨头螺钉位置不正确是螺钉穿出的预测因素。本研究基于博洛尼亚市马焦雷医院骨科和创伤科的经验,评估使用Elos髓内钉的治疗效果。我们对2017年1月1日至2022年12月31日期间接受Elos髓内钉治疗转子间股骨骨折的344例患者进行了回顾性队列研究。采用标准技术植入Elos创伤髓内钉。最初的X线片根据AO-OTA分类对骨折进行分类,术后X线片根据克利夫兰区域确认股骨头螺钉的位置。患者分为两组:最佳股骨头螺钉位置(5-8-9区)和其他位置。我们使用Chang标准评估TAD、距骨皮质TAD(CalTAD)和术后复位质量。结合这些测量评估螺钉穿出和其他并发症的发生率。在344例患者中,227例(65.9%)的螺钉位于5-8-9区,而117例(34.1%)的螺钉位于其他位置。TAD中位数为19.47±6.26 mm(范围3.96-46.6),265例患者(77%)的TAD≤25 mm。CalTAD中位数为22.37±5.65 mm(范围8.75-45.3),231例患者(67.1%)的CalTAD≤25 mm。根据Chang标准,8例(2.3%)复位不佳,139例(40.4%)复位可接受,197例(57.3%)复位优良。4例(1.19%)发生螺钉穿出。多因素分析显示,只有复位不佳和TAD>25 mm是螺钉穿出的独立预测因素(<0.05),而股骨头螺钉位置、CalTAD和骨折类型对螺钉穿出发生率无影响。本研究表明,最佳TAD和复位质量对于将螺钉穿出风险降至最低至关重要。当满足这些参数时,Elos髓内钉显示出良好的治疗效果,螺钉穿出发生率较低。应强调实现TAD≤25 mm和优良的复位质量以减少并发症。