Ibrahim Ateya Megahed, Abdel-Aziz Hassanat Ramadan, Fathi Zaghamir Donia Elsaid, Elneblawi Nora H, Elsaied Elhoty Mohamed Abd El-Rahman, Sweelam Rasha Kamal, Osman Mohamed Heba Ahmed, Elsaid Hassabelnaby Fathia Gamal
College of Nursing, Prince Sattam Bin Abdulaziz University, Alkharj, Saudi Arabia.
Family and Community Health Nursing Department, Faculty of Nursing, Port Said University, Port Said, Egypt.
Palliat Support Care. 2025 May 30;23:e108. doi: 10.1017/S1478951525000458.
End-of-life care poses significant ethical challenges for nurses, requiring a deep understanding of moral empathy and ethical decision-making. This study examines the impact of these factors on end-of-life decision-making among nurses in oncology and pain management units in Egypt.
A cross-sectional design was employed to gather data from participants at a single point in time, facilitating an analysis of the relationships among ethical principles, moral empathy, and nursing practice. The study involved 246 registered nurses with at least 6 months of experience, selected through stratified random sampling from oncology and pain management units in Damietta, Egypt. These settings were chosen due to their central role in palliative care, as Damietta serves as a regional healthcare hub with specialized units addressing chronic and end-of-life conditions. This selection allows for an in-depth exploration of the ethical dimensions involved in providing palliative care. Informed consent was acquired from all participants, ensuring confidentiality and the right to withdraw from the study at any time.
The findings indicated that 72% of participants reported high levels of moral empathy, which positively correlated with ethical decision-making scores ( = 0.65, < 0.01). However, 58% of the nurses also reported experiencing moderate to high levels of moral distress in various clinical scenarios. Additionally, nurses in supportive ethical climates experienced significantly lower moral distress than those in less supportive settings ( < 0.05).
This study highlights the importance of integrating ethical training and moral empathy into nursing education and practice. The findings underscore the need for policy reforms to embed ethics and empathy training in nursing curricula and professional development programs, fostering ethical competence and enhancing patient care quality.
临终护理给护士带来了重大的伦理挑战,这需要对道德同理心和伦理决策有深刻的理解。本研究考察了这些因素对埃及肿瘤学和疼痛管理科室护士临终决策的影响。
采用横断面设计,在单一时间点收集参与者的数据,以便分析伦理原则、道德同理心和护理实践之间的关系。该研究涉及246名具有至少6个月工作经验的注册护士,通过分层随机抽样从埃及达米埃塔的肿瘤学和疼痛管理科室选取。选择这些科室是因为它们在姑息治疗中发挥着核心作用,达米埃塔作为一个区域医疗中心,设有专门处理慢性和临终疾病的科室。这种选择能够深入探究提供姑息治疗所涉及的伦理层面。所有参与者均获得了知情同意,确保了保密性以及随时退出研究的权利。
研究结果表明,72%的参与者报告称具有高水平的道德同理心,这与伦理决策得分呈正相关(r = 0.65,p < 0.01)。然而,58%的护士也报告称在各种临床场景中经历了中度至高度的道德困扰。此外,处于支持性伦理氛围中的护士所经历的道德困扰明显低于那些处于支持性较差环境中的护士(p < 0.05)。
本研究强调了将伦理培训和道德同理心融入护理教育与实践的重要性。研究结果强调了政策改革的必要性,即在护理课程和专业发展项目中纳入伦理和同理心培训,培养伦理能力并提高患者护理质量。