Sautchuk Carlos, Fagundes Guilherme M, Barretto Filho Henyo T
Department of Anthropology, University of Brasília, Brasília, Brazil.
Department of Anthropology, University of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil.
Conserv Biol. 2025 Jun;39(3):e70048. doi: 10.1111/cobi.70048.
We explore the relationship between protected areas (PAs) and traditional communities to further the proposition of conservation as a sociotechnical phenomenon. To do this, we use an anthropological empirical approach based on long-term ethnographic studies conducted in Brazil by 2 different researchers who lived among local fishers on the Amazon and Quilombolas in the Cerrado (a savanna). Both studies related to the establishment of terms of commitment between PAs and traditional communities in the context of participatory management. In one case, an agreement between the staff of the Lago Piratuba Biological Reserve and pirarucu fish harpooners from Sucuriju village regarding fishing methods is examined. The other case explores the transformations related to the ban on firebreaks practiced by Quilombola communities in the Cerrado region of central Brazil and the efforts by the managers of the Serra Geral do Tocantins Ecological Station to rehabilitate cultural burns. We find there were benefits to a sociotechnical approach to understanding environmental conservation. The permanence of the harpoon in the Amazon and the rehabilitation of firebreaks in the Cerrado reconfigure conservation and local communities' techniques. More generally, this perspective can help avoid a reified view of the traditional communities and an abstract perspective of conservation policies. We believe sociotechnical conservation is a transformative approach that can be used to improve conventional conservation perspectives.
我们探讨保护区(PAs)与传统社区之间的关系,以进一步推动将保护视为一种社会技术现象的主张。为此,我们采用一种基于人类学实证方法,该方法基于两位不同研究人员在巴西进行的长期人种志研究,他们分别生活在亚马逊地区的当地渔民和塞拉多(热带稀树草原)的基隆波拉人中间。这两项研究都涉及在参与式管理背景下保护区与传统社区之间承诺条款的制定。在一个案例中,研究了皮拉图巴湖生物保护区的工作人员与苏库里朱村的巨骨舌鱼鱼叉捕捞者之间关于捕鱼方法的协议。另一个案例探讨了与巴西中部塞拉多地区基隆波拉社区禁止开设防火带相关的转变,以及托坎廷斯河上游生态站的管理人员恢复文化烧荒的努力。我们发现,采用社会技术方法来理解环境保护是有好处的。亚马逊地区鱼叉的留存以及塞拉多地区防火带的恢复重新配置了保护措施和当地社区的技术。更普遍地说,这种观点有助于避免对传统社区的僵化看法以及对保护政策的抽象观点。我们认为社会技术保护是一种变革性方法,可用于改进传统的保护观点。