Date Shota, Kurumadani Hiroshi, Nakamae Nanako, Ishii Yosuke, Kurauchi Kazuya, Maniwa Naoki, Goto Naoya, Fukushima Toshiyuki, Hirao Ken, Sunagawa Toru
Laboratory of Analysis and Control of Upper Extremity Function, Graduate School of Biomedical & Health Sciences, Hiroshima University, Hiroshima, Japan.
Department of Biomechanics, Graduate School of Biomedical & Health Sciences, Hiroshima University, Hiroshima, Japan.
PLoS One. 2025 Jun 3;20(6):e0325359. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0325359. eCollection 2025.
Upper extremity position affects maximum pinch strength; however, there is no consensus regarding the posture of the three ulnar fingers during pinch strength testing, and existing studies have different flexion or extension posture, depending on the measurement method used. This study aimed to clarify the effect of ulnar finger posture on maximum pinch strength and to verify its reliability. Thirty-three participants (19 males and 14 females) performed maximum pulp-to-pulp pinching with both dominant and non-dominant hands. Their ulnar finger posture was tested in two positions (flexion and extension). Measurements were conducted on three separate days by two examiners. Pinch strengths were compared for ulnar finger posture, hand dominance, and sex. The intraclass correlation coefficient was calculated to assess intra-rater, inter-rater and test-retest reliability. Pinch strength in the flexion posture was significantly stronger than that in the extension posture, regardless of hand dominance or sex (1.34 times greater). Intra-rater reliability was good to excellent in the flexion posture (0.89-0.92) and moderate to good in the extension posture (0.71-0.89). Inter-rater reliability was moderate for both flexion and extension postures (flexion: 0.64-0.68, extension: 0.52-0.54). Test-retest reliability was good to excellent in the flexion posture (0.83-0.91) and moderate in the extension posture (0.71-0.72). These results indicate the importance of hand therapists instructing patients to flex their ulnar fingers during testing to obtain maximum and reliable pinch strength measurements, thereby enhancing the accuracy of hand functional assessment in clinical practice.
上肢位置会影响最大捏力;然而,在捏力测试期间,关于尺侧三指的姿势尚无共识,并且现有研究根据所使用的测量方法而有不同的屈曲或伸展姿势。本研究旨在阐明尺侧手指姿势对最大捏力的影响并验证其可靠性。33名参与者(19名男性和14名女性)用优势手和非优势手进行最大指腹对指腹捏力测试。他们的尺侧手指姿势在两个位置(屈曲和伸展)进行测试。由两名检查者在三个不同日期进行测量。比较了尺侧手指姿势、手的优势以及性别的捏力。计算组内相关系数以评估评分者内、评分者间和重测信度。无论手的优势或性别如何,屈曲姿势下的捏力均显著强于伸展姿势下的捏力(强1.34倍)。评分者内信度在屈曲姿势下为良好至优秀(0.89 - 0.92),在伸展姿势下为中等至良好(0.71 - 0.89)。评分者间信度在屈曲和伸展姿势下均为中等(屈曲:0.64 - 0.68,伸展:0.52 - 0.54)。重测信度在屈曲姿势下为良好至优秀(0.83 - 0.91),在伸展姿势下为中等(0.71 - 0.72)。这些结果表明手部治疗师指导患者在测试期间屈曲其尺侧手指以获得最大且可靠的捏力测量值的重要性,从而提高临床实践中手部功能评估的准确性。