Inam Esma, Güney Seda, Roes Martina
German Center for Neurodegenerative Diseases (DZNE), Witten Site, Germany.
Faculty of Sociology, University of Duisburg/Essen, Duisburg, Germany.
BMC Geriatr. 2025 Jun 5;25(1):411. doi: 10.1186/s12877-025-06031-3.
Among the ethnic minority groups in Germany, Turkish immigrants represent the largest community. At the same time, this target group is underrepresented in dementia care research, and there are unique challenges regarding the recruitment of this group for studies. Increasing the involvement of Turkish immigrants in dementia care research is essential for reducing dementia-related inequalities. The aim of this scoping review is to describe strategies for recruiting Turkish immigrants living with dementia and their caregiving relatives for dementia care research and to identify related recruitment challenges.
We conducted a scoping review including articles from peer-reviewed journals applying the methodological framework of Arksey and O'Malley and the PCC framework (P = Population, C = Concept, C = Context). We searched the MEDLINE, PsycINFO, CINAHL, and Scopus databases as well as the literature written in the German language in local university databases. There were no restrictions on publication dates or study types. Additionally, the references of the identified articles were manually searched, and relevant articles were added. The content analysis was used to synthesize the findings.
In total, 651 articles were screened, 15 of which were included in the review. Nine of the 15 articles were focused on the involvement of caregiving relatives, and six of the included articles were focused on people with dementia. The choice of recruitment strategies depended on the specific target group. Five main categories were identified based on the characteristics of the recruitment strategies implemented: Access to health environment, inclusive practices and cultural considerations, face-to-face interactions, technology-mediated access and engagement events. People with dementia were recruited predominantly through senior centres, hospitals, or home care providers; referrals from physicians; and databases/registries. The involvement of bilingual staff was a crucial strategy for achieving greater participation. Caregiving relatives were recruited mainly through dementia-related community organizations, settings, and social networks and through the involvement of bilingual staff. While facilitators play an essential role in engaging caregiving relatives, language and cultural barriers remain the most important barriers.
The persistent presence of language and cultural barriers requires a culturally sensitive recruitment approach to increase the involvement of Turkish immigrants living with dementia and their caregiving relatives in dementia care research.
在德国的少数民族群体中,土耳其移民是最大的群体。与此同时,这一目标群体在痴呆症护理研究中的代表性不足,并且在招募该群体参与研究方面存在独特挑战。增加土耳其移民参与痴呆症护理研究对于减少与痴呆症相关的不平等至关重要。本范围综述的目的是描述招募患有痴呆症的土耳其移民及其护理亲属参与痴呆症护理研究的策略,并确定相关的招募挑战。
我们进行了一项范围综述,纳入了来自同行评审期刊的文章,采用了阿克西和奥马利的方法框架以及PCC框架(P = 人群,C = 概念,C = 背景)。我们搜索了MEDLINE、PsycINFO、CINAHL和Scopus数据库以及当地大学数据库中用德语撰写的文献。对出版日期或研究类型没有限制。此外,对已识别文章的参考文献进行了手动搜索,并添加了相关文章。采用内容分析法对研究结果进行综合。
共筛选了651篇文章,其中15篇纳入综述。15篇文章中有9篇关注护理亲属的参与,纳入的文章中有6篇关注痴呆症患者。招募策略的选择取决于特定的目标群体。根据所实施的招募策略的特点确定了五个主要类别:进入健康环境、包容性做法和文化考量、面对面互动、技术介导的接触和参与活动。痴呆症患者主要通过老年中心、医院或家庭护理提供者、医生推荐以及数据库/登记处招募。双语工作人员的参与是实现更高参与度的关键策略。护理亲属主要通过与痴呆症相关的社区组织、场所和社交网络以及双语工作人员的参与来招募。虽然促进者在吸引护理亲属参与方面发挥着重要作用,但语言和文化障碍仍然是最重要的障碍。
语言和文化障碍的持续存在需要一种具有文化敏感性的招募方法,以增加患有痴呆症的土耳其移民及其护理亲属参与痴呆症护理研究的程度。