Czerniewicz Laura, Agherdien Najma, Badenhorst Johan, Belluigi Dina, Chambers Tracey, Chili Muntuwenkosi, de Villiers Magriet, Felix Alan, Gachago Daniela, Gokhale Craig, Ivala Eunice, Kramm Neil, Madiba Matete, Mistri Gitanjali, Mgqwashu Emmanuel, Pallitt Nicola, Prinsloo Paul, Solomon Kelly, Strydom Sonja, Swanepoel Mike, Waghid Faiq, Wissing Gerrit
University of Cape Town, Cape Town, 7700, South Africa.
University of Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, 2000, South Africa.
Postdigit Sci Educ. 2020;2(3):946-967. doi: 10.1007/s42438-020-00187-4. Epub 2020 Sep 23.
Produced from experiences at the outset of the intense times when Covid-19 lockdown restrictions began in March 2020, this collaborative paper offers the collective reflections and analysis of a group of teaching and learning and Higher Education (HE) scholars from a diverse 15 of the 26 South African public universities. In the form of a theorised narrative insistent on foregrounding personal voices, it presents a snapshot of the pandemic addressing the following question: what does the 'pivot online' to Emergency Remote Teaching and Learning (ERTL), forced into urgent existence by the Covid-19 pandemic, mean for equity considerations in teaching and learning in HE? Drawing on the work of Therborn (2009: 20-32; 2012: 579-589; 2013; 2020) the reflections consider the forms of inequality - vital, resource and existential - exposed in higher education. Drawing on the work of Tronto (1993; 2015; White and Tronto 2004) the paper shows the networks of care which were formed as a counter to the systemic failures of the sector at the onset of the pandemic.
这篇合作论文源自2020年3月新冠疫情封锁限制开始时的紧张时期的经历,它呈现了来自南非26所公立大学中15所不同大学的一群教学与高等教育(HE)学者的集体反思与分析。以一种强调个人声音的理论化叙述形式,它呈现了疫情期间的一个快照,探讨了以下问题:新冠疫情迫使紧急远程教学与学习(ERTL)迅速出现,向其“转向线上”对高等教育教学中的公平性考量意味着什么?借鉴瑟伯恩(2009:20 - 32;2012:579 - 589;2013;2020)的研究,这些反思考虑了高等教育中暴露的不平等形式——生命、资源和生存方面的不平等。借鉴特龙托(1993;2015;怀特和特龙托2004)的研究,本文展示了在疫情初期作为应对该部门系统性失灵而形成的关爱网络。