Li Jiaxiong, Li Chunying, Tang Haida
School of Architecture and Urban Planning, Shenzhen University, Shenzhen, 518060, China.
Faculty of Innovation and Design, City University of Macau, Macau, 999078, China.
J Build Eng. 2022 Jul 1;51:104255. doi: 10.1016/j.jobe.2022.104255. Epub 2022 Feb 23.
Airborne transmission is a possible infection route of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19). This investigation focuses on the airborne infection risk of COVID-19 in a nursing unit in an inpatient building in Shenzhen, China. On-site measurements and questionnaire surveys were conducted to obtain the air change rates and occupant trajectories, respectively. The aerosol transport and dose-response models were applied to evaluate the infection risk. The average outdoor air change rate measured in the wards was 1.1 h, which is below the minimum limit of 2.0 h required by ASHRAE 170-2021. Considering the surveyed occupant behavior during one week, the patients and their attendants spent an average of 19.4 h/d and 15.1 h/d, respectively, in the wards, whereas the nurses primarily worked in the nurse station (3.0 h/d) and wards (2.4 h/d). The doctors primarily worked in their offices (2.6 h/d) and wards (1.1 h/d). Assuming one undetected COVID-19 infector emitting severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) in the nursing unit, we calculated the accumulated viral dose and infection probabilities of the occupants. After one week, the cumulative infection risks of the patients and attendants were almost equal (0.002), and were higher than those of the nurses (0.0013) and doctors (0.0004). Proper protection measures, such as reducing the number of attendants, increasing the air change rate, and wearing masks, were found to reduce the infection risk. It should be noted that the reported results are based on several assumptions, such as the speculated virological properties of SARS-CoV-2 and the particular trajectories of occupants. Moreover, only second generations of transmission were taken into consideration, whereas in reality, the week-long exposure may cause third generation of transmission or worse.
空气传播是2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)的一种可能感染途径。本研究聚焦于中国深圳某住院楼护理单元内COVID-19的空气传播感染风险。分别进行了现场测量和问卷调查,以获取换气次数和人员活动轨迹。应用气溶胶传播和剂量反应模型来评估感染风险。病房实测的平均室外换气次数为1.1次/小时,低于美国采暖、制冷与空调工程师协会(ASHRAE)170-2021标准要求的最低限值2.0次/小时。考虑到一周内调查的人员行为,患者及其陪护人员在病房的平均停留时间分别为19.4小时/天和15.1小时/天,而护士主要在护士站(3.0小时/天)和病房(2.4小时/天)工作。医生主要在办公室(2.6小时/天)和病房(1.1小时/天)工作。假设护理单元内有一名未被发现的COVID-19感染者传播严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒2(SARS-CoV-2),我们计算了人员的累积病毒剂量和感染概率。一周后,患者和陪护人员的累积感染风险几乎相等(0.002),且高于护士(0.0013)和医生(0.0004)。研究发现,采取适当的防护措施,如减少陪护人员数量、增加换气次数和佩戴口罩,可降低感染风险。需要注意的是,报告的结果基于若干假设,如SARS-CoV-2的推测病毒学特性和人员的特定活动轨迹。此外,仅考虑了二代传播,而在现实中,长达一周的暴露可能会导致三代传播或更严重的情况。