Hurley Zoë, Al-Ali Khadija
Zayed University, Dubai, United Arab Emirates.
Public Authority for Applied Education and Training, Kuwait City, Kuwait.
Postdigit Sci Educ. 2021;3(3):771-792. doi: 10.1007/s42438-021-00254-4. Epub 2021 Sep 3.
During Covid-19, higher education made an unprecedented entry into the domestic sphere. However, not all students welcomed the emergency delivery of online courses. Consequently, some learners have been developing resistant practices to technology-driven learning, including being on mute and turning off cameras, but these silences, gaps and evasions are difficult to grasp through normative perspectives. Meanwhile, big tech continues to profit significantly from its encroachment on pedagogy. Conversely, we need alternate conceptions of learners' varying responses to technologies. To develop a novel perspective, the study considers the Middle East's traditional windows, which are carved through an elaborate wooden latticework screen of geometric patterns and designed to deflect rather than let in the light. This structure is applied as a theoretical metaphor to consider Arab women learners' technological veiled affordances of filters, avatars and not replying. The feminist postdigital framework develops unique inquiry into learners' subtle practices; the authors' self-reflexivity; and analysis of a (silent) email exchange and a Twitter avatar. Theorising suggests silences, invisibilities and disconnection are not necessarily a deficit but refractive responses enabling students and educators to stay below the radar.
在新冠疫情期间,高等教育以前所未有的方式进入了家庭领域。然而,并非所有学生都欢迎在线课程的紧急交付。因此,一些学习者一直在形成对技术驱动学习的抵制行为,包括静音和关闭摄像头,但这些沉默、差距和逃避行为很难从规范的角度去理解。与此同时,大型科技公司继续从其对教学法的侵蚀中大幅获利。相反,我们需要对学习者对技术的不同反应有不同的概念。为了形成一种新颖的视角,该研究考虑了中东地区传统的窗户,这些窗户是通过精心制作的几何图案木格子屏风雕刻而成,旨在反射光线而不是让光线进入。这种结构被用作一种理论隐喻,来思考阿拉伯女性学习者在技术方面的隐蔽能力,如使用滤镜、虚拟形象和不回复信息。女性主义后数字框架对学习者的微妙行为、作者的自我反思以及对(沉默的)电子邮件交流和推特虚拟形象的分析进行了独特的探究。理论分析表明,沉默、不可见和断开连接不一定是缺陷,而是一种折射反应,使学生和教育工作者能够保持低调。