Saban Theresia, Külzer Lea, Braun Andreas, Wenzler Johannes-Simon
Department of Operative Dentistry, Periodontology and Preventive Dentistry, RWTH Aachen University, 52074 Aachen, Germany.
J Clin Med. 2025 Jun 5;14(11):3997. doi: 10.3390/jcm14113997.
: The aim of this study was to investigate the effects of periodontal blood flow on the periapical region during various endodontic disinfection procedures. The hypothesis that periodontal blood flow reduces the increase in root surface temperature during disinfection procedures was tested. : One hundred and twenty extracted human teeth were shortened to 11 mm and the root canal was prepared using the F4 ProTaper Gold system. The specimens were covered with wax and then sealed in a thermoforming sheet, leaving a gap of 0.2 mm. Cannulas were attached to simulate stable fluid circulation. Thermographic evaluation was carried out using an infrared camera. The following methods were chosen for disinfection: I, λ445 nm diode laser (0.6 W, cw); II, λ445 nm diode laser, 3 W, pulsed, duty cycle 50%, 10 Hz; III, λ445 nm diode laser, 3 W, pulsed, duty cycle 75%, 10 Hz; IV, λ970 nm diode laser, 2 W, pulsed, duty cycle 50%, 10 Hz; V, λ970 nm diode laser, 2 W, pulsed, duty cycle 75%, 10 Hz; VI, experimental plasma device (2.5 W, 3.7 V); VII, heat plugger (200.0 °C); VIII, NaOCl 3% (60 °C). The results were analyzed statistically using the Kruskal-Wallis test. When there were significant differences between the groups ( < 0.05), the pairwise Mann-Whitney test with sequential Bonferroni correction was applied. : The smallest temperature changes, with a median value of 0.82 °C (max. 2.02 °C, min. 0.15 °C, IQR 0.87 °C), were observed using the laser at a setting of λ445 nm, 0.6 W cw, and a circulation rate of 6 mL/min. The highest temperature changes were measured at a fluid circulation rate of 0 mL/min with a laser setting of λ445 nm, 3 W, pulsed, duty cycle 75% with a median value of 21.7 °C (max. 25.02 °C, min. 20.29 °C, IQR 2.04 °C). : Disinfection procedures with laser, NaOCl, and an experimental plasma device can lead to an increase in root surface temperature. With the exception of the heat plugger, no significant temperature changes were observed. This study was conducted in vitro, which may limit the direct applicability of the results to clinical scenarios. Nevertheless, the simulation of blood flow showed a thermally protective effect, suggesting that clinical protocols should consider this variable when selecting thermal disinfection methods. These results support the hypothesis that periodontal blood flow may have a potentially positive influence on temperature changes during disinfection procedures.
本研究的目的是调查在各种牙髓消毒程序中牙周血流对根尖周区域的影响。对牙周血流可减少消毒程序中牙根表面温度升高这一假设进行了检验。120颗拔除的人牙被截短至11毫米,并使用F4 ProTaper Gold系统预备根管。标本用蜡覆盖,然后密封在热成型片材中,留出0.2毫米的间隙。连接插管以模拟稳定的液体循环。使用红外相机进行热成像评估。选择以下方法进行消毒:I,波长445纳米二极管激光器(0.6瓦,连续波);II,波长445纳米二极管激光器,3瓦,脉冲,占空比50%,10赫兹;III,波长445纳米二极管激光器,3瓦,脉冲,占空比75%,10赫兹;IV,波长970纳米二极管激光器,2瓦,脉冲,占空比50%,10赫兹;V,波长970纳米二极管激光器,2瓦,脉冲,占空比75%,10赫兹;VI,实验性等离子体装置(2.5瓦,3.7伏);VII,热充填器(200.0℃);VIII,3%次氯酸钠(60℃)。使用Kruskal-Wallis检验对结果进行统计学分析。当组间存在显著差异(<0.05)时,应用经连续Bonferroni校正的两两Mann-Whitney检验。使用波长445纳米、0.6瓦连续波的激光器且循环速率为6毫升/分钟时,观察到最小的温度变化,中位数为0.82℃(最大值2.02℃,最小值0.15℃,四分位距0.87℃)。在液体循环速率为0毫升/分钟、激光器设置为波长445纳米、3瓦、脉冲、占空比75%时测量到最高的温度变化,中位数为21.7℃(最大值25.02℃,最小值20.29℃,四分位距2.04℃)。用激光、次氯酸钠和实验性等离子体装置进行消毒程序会导致牙根表面温度升高。除热充填器外,未观察到显著的温度变化。本研究是在体外进行的,这可能会限制结果对临床情况的直接适用性。然而,血流模拟显示出热保护作用,表明临床方案在选择热消毒方法时应考虑这一变量。这些结果支持了牙周血流可能对消毒程序中的温度变化产生潜在积极影响这一假设。