Mensger Christina, Poehner Julien, Jansky Maximiliane, Jiao Yang, Nauck Friedemann, Stanze Henrikje
Institute of Public Health, Charité-Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Charitéplatz 1, 10117 Berlin, Germany.
Centre for Nursing Research and Counselling, School of Social Science, Hochschule Bremen-City University of Applied Sciences, Am Brill 2-4, 28195 Bremen, Germany.
Healthcare (Basel). 2025 May 27;13(11):1264. doi: 10.3390/healthcare13111264.
: Voluntary stopping of eating and drinking (VSED) is a way to hasten death or end life prematurely. VSED is controversial, and research is essential to inform this debate. The aim was to systematically synthesize empirical data on the attitudes, motives, and experiences related to VSED from the perspective of caregivers. : This systematic mixed-methods review (PROSPERO CRD42022283743) included qualitative and quantitative research. The MEDLINE, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Google Scholar, and BELIT databases were searched for English and German articles published between 1 January 2013 and 12 November 2021. Studies examining experiences, attitudes, and knowledge regarding VSED were eligible. We analyzed the data inductively after quantitative data transformation. Quality and confidence were assessed using the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool (MMAT) and GRADE-CERQual approach, respectively. : We identified 22 articles, including 16 studies. The participants were healthcare professionals and relatives, but not those who chose VSED. The motives for VSED are based on high symptom burdens and are closely related to self-determination. Most perceive VSED as a natural death and accept the patient's decision. However, this acceptance also depends on other factors, such as patient characteristics. Most healthcare professionals would accompany patients during VSED, sometimes leading to advocacy. Relatives often play an active role in VSED and may experience distressing grief if they struggle with their support or the dying situation. The confidence in the review findings ranged from moderate to very low. Our findings on the challenging and positive experiences related to VSED and the resulting needs have been published elsewhere. : VSED is a complex phenomenon affecting patients, nursing staff, physicians, and relatives. We provide an empirical basis for VSED to support research, debate, and practice.
自愿停止进食和饮水(VSED)是一种加速死亡或过早结束生命的方式。VSED存在争议,开展研究对于为这场辩论提供信息至关重要。其目的是从护理人员的角度系统地综合有关VSED的态度、动机和经历的实证数据。
这项系统性混合方法综述(PROSPERO CRD42022283743)包括定性和定量研究。检索了MEDLINE、CINAHL、PsycINFO、谷歌学术和BELIT数据库,以查找2013年1月1日至2021年11月12日期间发表的英文和德文文章。研究VSED的经历、态度和知识的研究符合要求。在对定量数据进行转换后,我们对数据进行了归纳分析。分别使用混合方法评估工具(MMAT)和GRADE-CERQual方法评估质量和可信度。
我们确定了22篇文章,包括16项研究。参与者是医疗保健专业人员和亲属,但不包括选择VSED的人。VSED的动机基于高症状负担,且与自主决定权密切相关。大多数人将VSED视为自然死亡并接受患者的决定。然而,这种接受也取决于其他因素,如患者特征。大多数医疗保健专业人员会在VSED期间陪伴患者,有时会进行支持。亲属在VSED中往往发挥积极作用,如果他们在提供支持或面对临终情况时感到挣扎,可能会经历痛苦的悲伤。对综述结果的信心从中度到非常低不等。我们关于VSED的具有挑战性和积极的经历以及由此产生的需求的研究结果已在其他地方发表。
VSED是一个影响患者、护理人员、医生和亲属的复杂现象。我们为VSED提供了实证依据,以支持研究、辩论和实践。