Koch Tom
University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
HEC Forum. 2025 Sep;37(3):379-387. doi: 10.1007/s10730-025-09551-y. Epub 2025 Jun 13.
In a November 2024 article of this journal Don A. Merrill suggested Tom Koch's (2023) article "A Skeptic's Report" either misunderstood or did not understand a "slippery slope argument". That article was an attempt to answer earlier authors who asked if the concerns of researchers prior to enabling legislation had been fulfilled. The "slippery slope" was one. In this article, the nature of those early concerns are again considered in relation to the nature of the "slippery slope event" that has resulted in an increasing annual number of deaths with progressively looser requirements for early medical termination. Like the original article, it uses Health Canada data to describe what has occurred, not a predictive argument on what may be.
在本期刊2024年11月的一篇文章中,唐·A·梅里尔指出,汤姆·科赫(2023年)的文章《怀疑论者的报告》要么误解了,要么没有理解“滑坡论证”。那篇文章试图回应早期作者提出的问题,即立法前研究人员的担忧是否得到了满足。“滑坡”就是其中一个担忧。在本文中,将再次结合“滑坡事件”的性质来考虑这些早期担忧的本质,“滑坡事件”导致每年死亡人数不断增加,同时早期医疗终止的要求也越来越宽松。与原文一样,本文使用加拿大卫生部的数据来描述已经发生的事情,而不是对可能发生的事情进行预测性论证。