Civetta J M, Hudson-Civetta J A
Ann Surg. 1985 Oct;202(4):524-32. doi: 10.1097/00000658-198510000-00013.
We believed that the dilemma of controlling costs yet maintaining quality of care might be approached in 10 ways designed to improve efficiency of care: principles of management, elimination of standing orders, classification of patients, written guidelines, mandatory communication, no repetitive orders, single order for single test, removal of monitoring catheters, constant administrative attention, and feedback. We monitored quality of care using the therapeutic intervention scoring system (TISS), mortality, utilization of bed days in the ICU, and the total hospitalization of 50 patients treated in April 1983 and, 8 months after the interventions, 50 patients treated in February 1984. There were no differences in the patient population, severity, outcome, or days. The total lab bills were $10,000 in 1983 and $6300 in 1984 (p less than 0.01). The total number of tests decreased by 2803 (42%) from 6685 to 3882, or 56 per patient per admission. Calculated ICU laboratory charges per patient decreased $3226 (53%) from $6210 to $2894. In 1983, while patients spent 15% of their hospital days in the ICU, they accumulated 61% of their total laboratory charges. In 1984, ICU days were 19% and ICU laboratory charges were 46% of the total. If the decrease of $3226 per patient is extrapolated to a year's population, this would decrease charges by over $2,000,000 in one 12-bed surgical ICU.
我们认为,可以通过旨在提高医疗效率的10种方法来解决控制成本与维持医疗质量这一两难问题:管理原则、取消长期医嘱、患者分类、书面指南、强制沟通、不重复开医嘱、单项检查单项医嘱、拔除监测导管、持续的行政关注以及反馈。我们使用治疗干预评分系统(TISS)、死亡率、重症监护病房(ICU)的床日使用率以及1983年4月接受治疗的50例患者的总住院时间来监测医疗质量,在干预措施实施8个月后,又监测了1984年2月接受治疗的50例患者的情况。患者群体、病情严重程度、治疗结果或住院天数均无差异。1983年的实验室总费用为10,000美元,1984年为6300美元(p值小于0.01)。检查总数从6685项减少到3882项,减少了2803项(42%),即每次入院每位患者减少56项。计算得出每位患者的ICU实验室费用从6210美元降至2894美元,减少了3226美元(53%)。1983年,患者在ICU度过了15%的住院天数,却累积了61%的实验室总费用。1984年,ICU天数占总天数的19%,ICU实验室费用占总费用的46%。如果将每位患者减少的3226美元费用推算至一年的患者群体,那么在一个拥有12张床位的外科ICU中,这将使费用减少超过2,000,000美元。