Sola-Martinez Alba, Gutiérrez-Puertas Vanesa, Galera-Barbero Trinidad Maria, Gutiérrez-Puertas Lorena
Department of Midwifery, Hospital La Inmaculada, Spain.
Department of Nursing, Physiotherapy and Medicine, Universidad de Almeria, Spain; Department of Hematology and Midwifery, Hospital Universitario Torrecárdenas, Spain; Research Group for Electronic Communications and Telemedicine TIC-019, Universidad de Almeria, Spain.
Women Birth. 2025 Jul;38(4):101938. doi: 10.1016/j.wombi.2025.101938. Epub 2025 Jun 13.
Planned home birth is a practice that remains uncommon in Spain, and research on midwives' perspectives regarding the facilitation of planned home births is scarce.
The quality of care in planned home births assisted by midwives is increasingly improving. However, in Spain, the supported of planned home births remains a controversial topic and is a practice rarely undertaken by midwives.
The objective of this study was to describe the perceptions and views of midwives working in the clinical setting of the Spanish public healthcare system regarding the supported of planned home births.
A qualitative descriptive design, using thematic analysis was employed. Semi-structured interviews and focus group were conducted in 2024 with midwives working in the Spanish public health care setting (n = 14).
Three main themes were developed reflecting the patterns of meaning constructed through the data analysis: a) Perceived barriers and benefits of planned home birth with the subthemes "identifying obstacles to implementing planned home birth" and "motivations offered by the process"; b) The duality that accompanies home birth with the subthemes "in the shadows of the underground" and "demystifying the process"; c) The struggle for recognition with subthemes "integrating planned home birth into the public health system" and "promoting the path toward change".
Participants identified the factors and challenges that interfere with the facilitation of planned home births, emphasizing the need to develop strategies and initiatives with significant impact at governmental, professional, and social.
The data obtained provide an opportunity to reflect on the importance of including planned home birth support within the healthcare system.
计划在家分娩在西班牙仍然是一种不常见的做法,关于助产士对促进计划在家分娩的看法的研究很少。
由助产士协助的计划在家分娩的护理质量正在不断提高。然而,在西班牙,计划在家分娩的支持仍然是一个有争议的话题,并且是助产士很少进行的一种做法。
本研究的目的是描述在西班牙公共医疗系统临床环境中工作的助产士对计划在家分娩支持的看法和观点。
采用定性描述性设计,运用主题分析法。2024年对在西班牙公共卫生保健环境中工作的助产士(n = 14)进行了半结构化访谈和焦点小组讨论。
通过数据分析得出了三个主要主题,反映了构建的意义模式:a)计划在家分娩的感知障碍和益处,子主题为“确定实施计划在家分娩的障碍”和“该过程提供的动机”;b)伴随在家分娩的二元性,子主题为“在地下的阴影中”和“揭开过程的神秘面纱”;c)争取认可的斗争,子主题为“将计划在家分娩纳入公共卫生系统”和“推动变革之路”。
参与者确定了干扰计划在家分娩促进的因素和挑战,强调需要在政府、专业和社会层面制定具有重大影响的战略和举措。
获得的数据为反思在医疗系统中纳入计划在家分娩支持的重要性提供了一个机会。