Zeng Yao-Zhen
Department of English, National Taiwan Normal University, 162 Heping East Road, Daan District, Taipei City 106, Taiwan.
J Acoust Soc Am. 2025 Jun 1;157(6):4513-4525. doi: 10.1121/10.0036905.
This study examined how phonetic characteristics differ across three speech conditions: Mandarin-only, English-only, and code-switched speech (where speakers switch between languages). To explore this, the study looked at three elements: sentences, phrases, and keywords within these conditions. Principal component analysis (PCA) was used to identify which components can best differentiate between these speech conditions. The results showed that the first three main components-overall pitch, vocal variability (jitter, shimmer, and harmonics-to-noise ratio or HNR), and pitch variability at the sentence level-explained 78.8% of the variation between the speech conditions. The findings revealed that Mandarin-only speech and code-switched speech involved more flexible and dynamic pitch modulation compared to English-only speech. This difference was likely due to the cognitive and phonological demands of Mandarin as a tonal language, as well as the added complexity of switching between two languages in code-switched speech. Additionally, vocal variability differed significantly across speech conditions, suggesting that differences in phonation type between Mandarin and English also played a crucial role in shaping their phonetic characteristics. Code-switched speech showed the most instability in vocal variability, Mandarin-only speech showed moderate instability, while English-only speech demonstrated the highest stability.
仅使用普通话、仅使用英语以及语码转换言语(即说话者在两种语言之间切换)。为了探究这一点,该研究着眼于这些条件下的三个要素:句子、短语和关键词。主成分分析(PCA)被用于确定哪些成分能够最好地区分这些言语条件。结果表明,前三个主要成分——整体音高、嗓音可变性(抖动、闪烁和谐波噪声比或HNR)以及句子层面的音高可变性——解释了言语条件之间78.8%的变异。研究结果显示,与仅使用英语的言语相比,仅使用普通话的言语和语码转换言语涉及更灵活、更动态的音高调制。这种差异可能是由于普通话作为一种声调语言的认知和音系学要求,以及语码转换言语中在两种语言之间切换所增加的复杂性。此外,嗓音可变性在不同言语条件下存在显著差异,这表明普通话和英语之间发声类型的差异在塑造它们的语音特征方面也起着关键作用。语码转换言语在嗓音可变性方面表现出最大的不稳定性,仅使用普通话的言语表现出中等程度的不稳定性,而仅使用英语的言语则表现出最高的稳定性。