Dadgostar Porooshat, Qin Qiuyuan, Cui Suiyue, Ashcraft Laura Ellen, Yousefi-Nooraie Reza
Department of Public Health Sciences, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, NY, United States.
Department of Biostatistics, Epidemiology, and Informatics, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, United States.
J Med Internet Res. 2025 Jun 20;27:e57370. doi: 10.2196/57370.
Compared with implementation, the conceptual frameworks, strategies, and outcomes of efforts to disseminate behavioral interventions are less developed. We conducted a scoping review of the systematic reviews of social media strategies to disseminate behavior change interventions. We focused on the common themes in the methodology and evaluation frameworks of social media-based dissemination strategies.
This scoping review aims to identify common themes in the design, delivery, and impact assessment of social media-based dissemination strategies for behavior change interventions.
We searched the Epistemonikos database (until 2024) to retrieve systematic reviews on social media dissemination. A total of 2 independent reviewers screened the abstracts and full texts. We extracted and classified the data on the characteristics of the included reviews and outcome assessments. We followed the reflexive thematic analysis steps to identify the main themes of the ingredients of the social media dissemination strategies.
We screened 613 records based on the title and abstract, followed by the assessment of 100 full texts of potentially eligible reviews. The 43 included reviews assessed a median of 20 empirical studies (IQ range 21). The study designs, intervention strategies, and evaluation measures of social media dissemination interventions were diverse. We classified the main themes of the ingredients of social media dissemination strategies into 4 main categories: 1-way spread (aiming for spread and diffusion, with little or no effort to develop 2-way communications or engage target users in conversation and feedback; n=37), invoking conversations (facilitating and enhancing the 1-way spread using conversational and community features of social media to promote dialogue among users or between the users and experts; n=21), peer motivation (facilitate sharing individual behavior on social media to receive confirmation, feedback, and support, to further personalize the dissemination; n=11), and miscellaneous (eg, dissemination through online multiplayer games; n=3). The main outcomes of dissemination efforts were reach and engagement (n=12), user perception of their knowledge, intention to change the behavior, feasibility and acceptability of the intervention (n=24), and impact on health and health-related behaviors (n=43). The majority of theoretical frameworks that were identified by the reviews were individual and social behavior change models (including the theory of planned behavior and Social Cognitive Theories). A smaller number of reviews also identified social and contextual models (eg, Social Network Theory), dissemination and implementation frameworks (eg, Diffusion of Innovation), and social marketing and action models (eg, community mobilization and Reader-to-Leader framework).
Researchers use various features of social media (eg, peer-to-peer sharing, online engagement in conversations, one-on-one, or with a broad audience), formation of clusters and communities, and peer feedback to complement and enhance the 1-way dissemination. Further research is needed to inform the theoretical underpinnings and the interventional ingredients of social media dissemination strategies.
与实施相比,传播行为干预措施的概念框架、策略和成果发展得不够完善。我们对关于传播行为改变干预措施的社交媒体策略的系统评价进行了一项范围综述。我们关注基于社交媒体的传播策略在方法和评价框架方面的共同主题。
本范围综述旨在确定基于社交媒体的行为改变干预措施传播策略在设计、实施和影响评估方面的共同主题。
我们检索了Epistemonikos数据库(截至2024年),以获取关于社交媒体传播的系统评价。共有2名独立评审员筛选摘要和全文。我们提取并分类了纳入评价的特征和结果评估的数据。我们遵循反思性主题分析步骤,以确定社交媒体传播策略要素的主要主题。
我们根据标题和摘要筛选了613条记录,随后对100篇可能符合条件的评价全文进行了评估。纳入的43篇评价中位数评估了20项实证研究(四分位间距21)。社交媒体传播干预措施的研究设计、干预策略和评价措施各不相同。我们将社交媒体传播策略要素的主要主题分为4大类:单向传播(旨在传播和扩散,几乎或根本没有努力发展双向沟通或让目标用户参与对话和反馈;n = 37)、引发对话(利用社交媒体的对话和社区功能促进和增强单向传播,以促进用户之间或用户与专家之间的对话;n = 21)、同伴激励(促进在社交媒体上分享个人行为以获得确认、反馈和支持,以进一步使传播个性化;n = 11)和其他(例如,通过在线多人游戏进行传播;n = 3)。传播努力的主要结果是覆盖面和参与度(n = 12)、用户对其知识的认知、改变行为的意图、干预措施的可行性和可接受性(n = 24)以及对健康和与健康相关行为的影响(n = 43)。评价中确定的大多数理论框架是个人和社会行为改变模型(包括计划行为理论和社会认知理论)。少数评价还确定了社会和背景模型(例如,社会网络理论)、传播和实施框架(例如,创新扩散)以及社会营销和行动模型(例如,社区动员和读者到领导者框架)。
研究人员利用社交媒体的各种特征(例如,点对点分享、在线参与对话、一对一或面向广泛受众)以及集群和社区的形成以及同伴反馈来补充和增强单向传播。需要进一步研究以阐明社交媒体传播策略的理论基础和干预要素。