Ahn Jiseul Sophia, Ratelle Catherine F, Duchesne Stéphane, Plamondon André
School of Psychoeducation, Université de Montréal, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Faculty of Educational Sciences, Université Laval, Quebec, QC, Canada.
J Career Dev. 2025 Jun 14;52(4):449-468. doi: 10.1177/08948453251351576. eCollection 2025 Aug.
A sense of agency is crucial for self-directed career development, particularly during the postsecondary transition, a period shaping career trajectories. This study examined autonomy and self-efficacy as pillars of agency, using longitudinal data from a sample of 637 French-Canadian adolescents (54% girls, = 16) before and after the transition. Participants reported on career decision-making autonomy (intrinsic, identified, introjected, and external motivations) and self-efficacy, along with career exploration and commitment. Latent profile analysis identified four subgroups of youth, including youth with high autonomous motivations and self-efficacy, displaying a fully agentic profile, and others with lop-sided agency, marked by strong controlled motivations. Relative weigh analysis indicated self-efficacy as the strongest predictor, with intrinsic motivation making a unique albeit weaker contribution to exploration. These findings highlight the importance of fostering both autonomy and competence, while also revealing the detrimental implication of reward- and punishment-driven motivation on career identity integration.
自主感对于自我导向的职业发展至关重要,尤其是在高等教育过渡阶段,这是一个塑造职业轨迹的时期。本研究以637名法裔加拿大青少年(54%为女孩,平均年龄 = 16岁)在过渡前后的纵向数据为样本,考察了自主性和自我效能感作为自主感的支柱。参与者报告了职业决策自主性(内在、认同、投射和外部动机)、自我效能感以及职业探索和职业承诺。潜在剖面分析确定了四个青年亚组,包括具有高度自主动机和自我效能感、展现出完全自主特征的青年,以及其他具有不平衡自主特征的青年,其特点是有强烈的受控动机。相对权重分析表明自我效能感是最强预测因素,内在动机对职业探索虽有独特贡献但较弱。这些发现凸显了培养自主性和能力的重要性,同时也揭示了奖励和惩罚驱动的动机对职业认同整合的不利影响。