Casado-Arroyo Ruben, Osoro Lucia
Department of Cardiology, H.U.B.-Hôpital Erasme, Université Libre de Bruxelles, 1070 Brussels, Belgium.
J Mark Access Health Policy. 2025 Jun 9;13(2):30. doi: 10.3390/jmahp13020030. eCollection 2025 Jun.
Innovation is a key enabler of patient-centered care in cardiology, with new medical devices and digital health technologies offering the potential to improve outcomes and efficiency. However, the evaluation of these innovations poses challenges for clinicians, regulators, and procurement stakeholders, particularly within the complex European healthcare landscape. This review aims to explore the current state of health technology assessment (HTA) for cardiology-related medical devices in Europe, offering a clinical perspective. Three independent scoping reviews were conducted following the PRISMA-ScR guidelines. Keywords included "innovation", "health technology assessment", and "cardiology". The search was supplemented by the relevant literature on European HTA policies, regulatory directives, and emerging technologies. The review identified three central themes: (1) the evolving role of clinicians in HTA processes, (2) the integration of innovative technologies such as digital tools and artificial intelligence within HTA frameworks, and (3) the considerable variation in HTA practices and policies across EU member states. HTA in Europe is undergoing a transformation, with increasing emphasis on interdisciplinary collaboration and frameworks that support innovation. While the goal of harmonization across the EU remains a work in progress, new regulatory efforts, such as the HTA Regulation (HTAR), offer promising avenues for aligning clinical practice with evidence-based assessment and reimbursement decisions.
创新是心脏病学中以患者为中心的医疗服务的关键推动因素,新的医疗设备和数字健康技术有望改善治疗效果并提高效率。然而,对这些创新的评估给临床医生、监管机构和采购利益相关者带来了挑战,尤其是在复杂的欧洲医疗环境中。本综述旨在从临床角度探讨欧洲心脏病学相关医疗设备的健康技术评估(HTA)现状。按照PRISMA-ScR指南进行了三项独立的范围综述。关键词包括“创新”、“健康技术评估”和“心脏病学”。通过有关欧洲HTA政策、监管指令和新兴技术的相关文献对搜索进行了补充。该综述确定了三个核心主题:(1)临床医生在HTA过程中不断演变的作用;(2)数字工具和人工智能等创新技术在HTA框架内的整合;(3)欧盟成员国之间HTA实践和政策存在相当大的差异。欧洲的HTA正在经历变革,越来越强调跨学科合作以及支持创新的框架。虽然欧盟范围内协调统一的目标仍在推进中,但新的监管举措,如HTA法规(HTAR),为使临床实践与基于证据的评估和报销决策保持一致提供了有前景的途径。