d'Agostino Marco, Zenga Emanuele Luigi, Giovanetti Manuela, Bitonto Fortunato Fulvio, Galloni Marta, Quaranta Marino, Bortolotti Laura
CREA Research Centre for Agriculture and Environment, Bologna, Italy.
Department of Agricultural, Forest, and Food Sciences, University of Turin, Turin, Italy.
Biol Futur. 2025 Jun 27. doi: 10.1007/s42977-025-00268-0.
Given the growing importance of assessing the condition of wild bees in agroecosystems, we focused on developing a BEE indicator that could be easily used by non-expert taxonomists to score bee diversity. Our goal was to create a tool suitable for farm-level use, one that does not require taxonomic expertise nor heavy field work. Since existing literature has emphasized the significance of environmental features surrounding any investigated site, we incorporated this aspect into our design. We began by identifying a user-friendly field tool to differentiate among bee morphogenera, then proceeded by developing a process for data analyses and interpretation. A protocol is also shared. Further on, we run a case-study testing this tool at 13 sites in three countries, differentiating farms based on farming practices (conventional or organic, as proxy of opposite conditions). The results confirmed that (a) a diagnostic table based on morphological similarities is a practical field tool that, in almost all cases, allows for accurate classification of a bee individual into a specific group (morphogenus); (b) the process of analysis, based on number of morphogenera and landscape composition reflects variability among bees and across sites; (c) evaluating environmental features is essential for placing the results of bee variability into the appropriate context.
鉴于评估农业生态系统中野生蜜蜂状况的重要性日益增加,我们专注于开发一种蜜蜂指标,非专业分类学家可以轻松使用该指标对蜜蜂多样性进行评分。我们的目标是创建一种适用于农场层面使用的工具,该工具既不需要分类学专业知识,也不需要繁重的野外工作。由于现有文献强调了任何调查地点周围环境特征的重要性,我们将这一方面纳入了我们的设计。我们首先确定了一种用户友好的野外工具,用于区分蜜蜂形态属,然后着手开发数据分析和解释流程。还分享了一个方案。此外,我们在三个国家的13个地点进行了案例研究,测试该工具,根据耕作方式(传统或有机,作为相反条件的代表)区分农场。结果证实:(a)基于形态相似性的诊断表是一种实用的野外工具,在几乎所有情况下,都能将蜜蜂个体准确分类到特定组(形态属);(b)基于形态属数量和景观组成的分析过程反映了蜜蜂之间以及不同地点的变异性;(c)评估环境特征对于将蜜蜂变异性结果置于适当背景下至关重要。