Hoevelmann Yannick, Ratter Annkathrin, Merkel Fabian, Hickert Sebastian, Konishcheva Evgeniia
Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany.
Anal Bioanal Chem. 2025 Jun 30. doi: 10.1007/s00216-025-05979-w.
RNA-based therapeutics, such as vaccines or gene therapy applications, are steadily gaining in popularity and require extensive analytical characterization with several orthogonal methods to ensure highest purity for safe use. In this study, size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) with multiple detectors was used for characterizing single- and double-stranded (ss/ds) RNA ladders, providing insights into how conformation and viscosity affect the different elution profiles observed for both species in SEC. Furthermore, high-resolution chromatographic separation was merged with the high-sensitivity detection provided by fluorescent dyes by developing an innovative approach relying on SEC with post-column nucleic acid staining and fluorescence detection (SEC-pcs-FLD). Herein, SEC-pcs-FLD was successfully applied to four out of five investigated dyes, namely SYBR Gold, SYBR Green I, Thiazole Orange, and YOYO-1, yielding a 10- to 150-fold sensitivity increase for mRNA detection compared to typically applied UV detection for chromatographic nucleic acid analysis. Besides the significant sensitivity increase, reproducibility and linearity regarding the response to concentration ratio were demonstrated for the post-column staining approach, indicating suitability for low-level RNA quantitation. Two of the investigated dyes, namely SYBR Green I and YOYO-1, further allowed for the differentiation of ssRNA and dsRNA species based on SEC-pcs-FLD, as they showed stronger affinity towards dsRNA reflected in a roughly five- to sixfold higher FLD/UV response ratio compared to ssRNA. This approach consequently also holds promise for the quantitation of dsRNA impurities potentially formed during mRNA synthesis and associated with causing innate immune responses, especially as currently applied methods like immunoassays show several limitations.
基于RNA的疗法,如疫苗或基因治疗应用,正越来越受欢迎,并且需要使用多种正交方法进行广泛的分析表征,以确保最高纯度以便安全使用。在本研究中,使用配备多个检测器的尺寸排阻色谱法(SEC)对单链和双链(ss/ds)RNA梯进行表征,从而深入了解构象和粘度如何影响在SEC中观察到的这两种物质的不同洗脱曲线。此外,通过开发一种基于柱后核酸染色和荧光检测的SEC创新方法(SEC-pcs-FLD),将高分辨率色谱分离与荧光染料提供的高灵敏度检测相结合。在此,SEC-pcs-FLD成功应用于所研究的五种染料中的四种,即SYBR Gold、SYBR Green I、噻唑橙和YOYO-1,与通常用于色谱核酸分析的紫外检测相比,mRNA检测的灵敏度提高了10至150倍。除了显著提高灵敏度外,柱后染色方法在浓度比响应方面的重现性和线性也得到了证明,表明其适用于低水平RNA定量。所研究的两种染料,即SYBR Green I和YOYO-1,基于SEC-pcs-FLD进一步实现了单链RNA和双链RNA种类的区分,因为它们对双链RNA显示出更强的亲和力,这反映在与单链RNA相比,荧光检测/紫外响应比大约高五到六倍。因此,这种方法也有望用于定量在mRNA合成过程中可能形成并与引发先天免疫反应相关的双链RNA杂质,特别是因为目前应用的方法如免疫测定显示出一些局限性。