Emogor Charles A, Balmford Andrew, Ingram Daniel J, Iferi Omini B, Imong Inaoyom, Ogu Dominic S, Coad Lauren
Department of Zoology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
Wildlife Conservation Society, Calabar, Nigeria.
Proc Biol Sci. 2025 Jul;292(2050):20250471. doi: 10.1098/rspb.2025.0471. Epub 2025 Jul 2.
Zoonotic diseases pose global public health threats, prompting various interventions to limit their emergence and spread. One increasingly common response by governments has been to ban wildlife hunting, trade and consumption. However, there is limited evidence of the effectiveness of wildlife trade bans. Here we assess compliance with Nigeria's wildlife trade ban-enacted to curb the spread of mpox (formerly monkeypox)-by analysing approximately 4.5 years of wild meat sales data from 19 vendors in southeast Nigeria (988 vendor-months) alongside interviews with vendors and law enforcement officials. After matching the sales data by time of year, we found no significant differences before and after the ban in the number of vendors selling wild meat per week, the weekly mass of wild meat sold, or the weekly price per kilogram of wild meat; however, the total weekly sales price was higher post-ban. These findings, supported by interview insights, indicate widespread non-compliance by vendors, questioning the ban's effectiveness. We propose that successful regulations require clear enforcement mechanisms, active public engagement and economic incentives to improve compliance. This study provides valuable insights for designing effective interventions to mitigate zoonotic spillovers.
人畜共患疾病对全球公共卫生构成威胁,促使人们采取各种干预措施来限制其出现和传播。政府越来越普遍的应对措施是禁止野生动物狩猎、贸易和消费。然而,野生动物贸易禁令有效性的证据有限。在此,我们通过分析尼日利亚东南部19家摊贩约4.5年的野肉销售数据(988个摊贩月)以及对摊贩和执法官员的访谈,评估尼日利亚为遏制猴痘(原称猴天花)传播而颁布的野生动物贸易禁令的遵守情况。在按年份匹配销售数据后,我们发现禁令前后每周销售野肉的摊贩数量、每周销售的野肉质量或每公斤野肉的每周价格均无显著差异;然而,禁令后每周销售总价更高。这些发现得到访谈见解的支持,表明摊贩普遍不遵守规定,这让人质疑该禁令的有效性。我们建议,成功的法规需要明确的执行机制、积极的公众参与和经济激励措施来提高遵守率。本研究为设计有效的干预措施以减轻人畜共患疾病的溢出效应提供了宝贵的见解。