Rahme Deema, Saade Daniele, Sacre Hala, Haddad Chadia, Tawil Samah, Merhi Samar, Aoun Randa, Hajj Aline, Sakr Fouad, Safwan Jihan, Akel Marwan, Zeenny Rony M, Salameh Pascale
Pharmacy Practice Department, Faculty of Pharmacy, Beirut Arab University, Beirut, Lebanon.
INSPECT-LB (Institut National de Santé Publique d'Épidémiologie Clinique et de Toxicologie-Liban), Beirut, Lebanon.
BMC Med Educ. 2025 Jul 1;25(1):886. doi: 10.1186/s12909-025-07448-5.
This study examines the impact of program accreditation on education quality and career outcomes among students and graduates of health-related disciplines in Lebanon. In the absence of a national accrediting body, many universities seek international accreditation. Additionally, the study validates four scales measuring factors influencing university choice and perceptions of accreditation.
A cross-sectional study was conducted between September and December 2023, enrolling 642 participants, including students and graduates from Lebanese health-related programs. Four validated scales included: Reasons for Choosing University Program (RCUP, 14 items), Perception of University Program Accreditation (PUPA, 12 items), Perceived Impact on Education Quality (PI-AQE, 27 items), and Perceived Impact on Career Outcomes (PI-ACO, 9 items). Principal component analysis with Promax rotation assessed construct validity. Bivariate analyses (t-tests and ANOVA) examined relationships between scales and participant characteristics. Multivariate analysis of covariance (MANCOVA) adjusted for sociodemographic and university-related factors, while multiple regression explored predictors of time to employment for graduates.
Students from three universities reported significantly lower RCUP scores, indicating weaker motivations for their program choice. Clear communication of accreditation status correlated positively with RCUP (β = 1.097, p = 0.004). Pharmacy students scored higher on RCUP (β = 2.412, p = 0.002). Higher income levels (β = 1.829, p = 0.020) and awareness of accreditation (β = 2.348, p = 0.004) were linked to more favorable PUPA scores. Females (β = 4.981, p = 0.002) and high-income individuals (β = 3.777, p = 0.040) anticipated a stronger impact on PI-AQE. Graduates, particularly those with a PhD (β = 4.755, p = 0.042) or a Bachelor's degree (β = 2.557, p = 0.003), expressed more positive PI-ACO perceptions. Conversely, uncertainty about accreditation was associated with lower PI-ACO scores (β = -3.019, p = 0.004). Notably, university accreditation status (β = -0.355, p = 0.011) and longer professional experience (β = -0.274, p = 0.010) were significantly linked to a shorter time to employment.
This study validates tools for assessing accreditation's impact on Lebanese health education. Findings emphasize that accreditation status, program choice, and demographics significantly shape perceptions of education quality and career prospects. Effective communication about accreditation may enhance career readiness and suggest potential benefits for employment prospects. These findings emphasize the importance of accreditation as a strategic tool for advancing health education quality and optimizing career prospects in the healthcare sector.
本研究探讨了项目认证对黎巴嫩健康相关学科的学生和毕业生的教育质量及职业成果的影响。在缺乏国家认证机构的情况下,许多大学寻求国际认证。此外,该研究验证了四个衡量影响大学选择及认证认知因素的量表。
于2023年9月至12月进行了一项横断面研究,招募了642名参与者,包括黎巴嫩健康相关项目的学生和毕业生。四个经过验证的量表包括:选择大学项目的原因(RCUP,14项)、对大学项目认证的认知(PUPA,12项)、对教育质量的感知影响(PI - AQE,27项)以及对职业成果的感知影响(PI - ACO,9项)。采用Promax旋转的主成分分析评估结构效度。双变量分析(t检验和方差分析)检验了量表与参与者特征之间的关系。多变量协方差分析(MANCOVA)对社会人口学和大学相关因素进行了调整,而多元回归探索了毕业生就业时间的预测因素。
来自三所大学的学生报告的RCUP分数显著较低,表明他们选择该项目的动机较弱。认证状态的清晰沟通与RCUP呈正相关(β = 1.097,p = 0.004)。药学专业学生的RCUP得分更高(β = 2.412,p = 0.002)。较高的收入水平(β = 1.829,p = 0.020)和认证意识(β = 2.348,p = 0.004)与更有利的PUPA分数相关。女性(β = 4.981,p = 0.002)和高收入个体(β = 3.777,p = 0.040)预计对PI - AQE有更强的影响。毕业生,尤其是那些拥有博士学位(β = 4.755,p = 0.042)或学士学位(β = 2.557,p = 0.003)的毕业生,对PI - ACO的认知更为积极。相反,认证的不确定性与较低的PI - ACO分数相关(β = -3.019,p = 0.004)。值得注意的是,大学认证状态(β = -0.355,p = 0.011)和更长的专业经验(β = -0.274,p = 0.010)与更短的就业时间显著相关。
本研究验证了评估认证对黎巴嫩健康教育影响的工具。研究结果强调,认证状态、项目选择和人口统计学显著影响对教育质量和职业前景的认知。关于认证的有效沟通可能会提高职业准备程度,并表明对就业前景有潜在益处。这些发现强调了认证作为提升健康教育质量和优化医疗保健行业职业前景的战略工具的重要性。