Spencer Margaret Beale
Comparative Human Development Department, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
J Res Adolesc. 2025 Sep;35(3):e70032. doi: 10.1111/jora.70032.
A specific theory-guided, humanity-focused perspective addresses the "how" and "why" of America's long-standing racial tension and the patterned problem of wrongful Black deaths. Qualitative data coding and analysis indicate interpersonal and relational misalignments between male youth of color (MYC) and law enforcement officers (LEO). LEO interview findings highlight professional support needs and safety-relevant tasks and responsibilities; however, MYC interview outcomes emphasize the challenges and assistance needed to successfully complete developmental tasks. The perceptions and reported behaviors of MYCs are highlighted based on data gathered from 44 audio-only one-hour youth interviews and 54 h-and-one-half audio-only Zoom interviews with sworn officers. Youth report that family socialization prepares them for successful encounters with LEOs as MYCs navigate ecologies and pursue developmental objectives. However, LEO judgments about MYC indicate significant expectation misalignments that overlook many youths' vulnerability status attributes, suggesting disconnects in how each group perceives the other. Youth describe parental emphasized respect and obedience socialization directives for use during anticipated interactions with police, which often go unrecognized by LEOs. Thus, familial "reciprocal socialization" instructions provided for youth indicate a source of misalignments in expectations given their apparent invisibility to LEOs; perceptions held by LEOs of MYC do not align with the respect and obedience emphasis provided the latter by families. Youths feel they intentionally follow familial expectations in their encounters, yet law enforcement professionals fail to acknowledge or recognize families' supportive socialization efforts. Inferred is that elements about the identity processes of LEOs and MYCs are consistent with Roberta Rosenberg Simmons's long-term insights.
一种特定的、以理论为指导且关注人性的视角探讨了美国长期存在的种族紧张关系的“方式”和“原因”以及黑人非正常死亡的模式化问题。定性数据编码和分析表明有色人种青年男性(MYC)与执法人员(LEO)之间存在人际和关系上的不协调。执法人员的访谈结果突出了专业支持需求以及与安全相关的任务和职责;然而,有色人种青年男性的访谈结果强调了成功完成发展任务所需面对的挑战和获得的帮助。基于从44次时长为一小时的纯音频青年访谈以及与宣誓就职的警官进行的54次时长为一个半小时的纯音频Zoom访谈中收集到的数据,突出了有色人种青年男性的看法和报告的行为。青年们表示,在有色人种青年男性应对各种环境并追求发展目标时,家庭社会化使他们为与执法人员的成功接触做好了准备。然而,执法人员对有色人种青年男性的判断显示出重大的期望错位,忽视了许多青年的脆弱状况属性,这表明两组人对彼此的认知存在脱节。青年们描述了父母强调在与警察预期互动中使用尊重和服从的社会化指令,但执法人员往往并未认识到这一点。因此,为青年提供的家庭“相互社会化”指示表明,由于执法人员显然对此视而不见,导致了期望的错位;执法人员对有色人种青年男性的认知与家庭给予后者的尊重和服从强调不一致。青年们觉得他们在接触中有意遵循家庭期望,但执法专业人员未能承认或认识到家庭支持性的社会化努力。由此推断,执法人员和有色人种青年男性身份认同过程的要素与罗伯塔·罗森伯格·西蒙斯的长期见解一致。