Godzik Cassandra M, DiBenedetto Jennifer K, Usset Timothy J, Stiles Heather, Klein Heather, Fortuna Karen, Pepin Renee, Wright Hannah, Locke Amy, Thomason Helen, Smith Andrew J
Department of Psychiatry, Dartmouth-Hitchcock Health System, Lebanon, NH, United States.
Geisel School of Medicine, Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH, United States.
Front Health Serv. 2025 Jun 23;5:1582700. doi: 10.3389/frhs.2025.1582700. eCollection 2025.
In the post-pandemic recovery era, addressing moral injury is critical due to high prevalence and impact on mental and occupational health. Interventions that address moral injury in hospital settings are limited. Further, engaging HCWs in any mental health interventions has proven challenging for a variety of reasons and exacerbated by factors such as a rural setting. Implementation science aimed at understanding barriers and facilitators to interventions is needed in order to build and offer interventions that are usable, feasible, acceptable, and effective. The current study aimed to understand such barriers and facilitators to building moral injury interventions for nurses on the medical intensive care unit (MICU).
We conducted semi-structured qualitative interviews using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Science Research (CFIR) and Peer and Academic Model of Community Engagement with 25 participants in a rural hospital system, 19 nurses currently working in the MICU and six nurses who left their MICU employment. Interviews were transcribed and analyzed using a thematic analysis approach.
There were five CFIR domains and 14 associated CFIR constructs that impacted intervention implementation in this population. Barriers included resource costs, skepticism regarding the effectiveness of new resources, lack of support from leaders, concerns that emotions affect professional image, inability to take breaks, and a disconnect between nurses' lived experiences and community perceptions. Facilitators included interventions specifically tailored for the MICU, strengths in teaming and social support among fellow nurses, and a desire for change because of factors such as a high turnover rate. Participants also highlighted a strong motivation to provide the best care possible and a desire to build resilience by supporting each other.
Analysis of barriers and facilitators suggests value in improving the opportunities for HCWs to process morally injurious experiences with interventions specific to a particular unit and resources such as peer support and chaplains. There is a demonstrated need for high-level organizational change to address the dynamic needs of our nurses.
在疫情后恢复时代,应对道德伤害至关重要,因为其患病率高且对心理和职业健康有影响。在医院环境中应对道德伤害的干预措施有限。此外,由于各种原因,让医护人员参与任何心理健康干预都已证明具有挑战性,而农村环境等因素会使情况更加恶化。为了构建并提供可用、可行、可接受且有效的干预措施,需要实施科学来了解干预的障碍和促进因素。本研究旨在了解在医疗重症监护病房(MICU)为护士构建道德伤害干预措施的此类障碍和促进因素。
我们使用实施科学研究综合框架(CFIR)以及社区参与的同伴和学术模型,对一家农村医院系统的25名参与者进行了半结构化定性访谈,其中19名是目前在MICU工作的护士,6名是已离开MICU岗位的护士。访谈进行了转录,并采用主题分析方法进行分析。
有五个CFIR领域和14个相关的CFIR构建体影响了该人群的干预实施。障碍包括资源成本、对新资源有效性的怀疑、缺乏领导支持、担心情绪影响职业形象、无法休息以及护士的生活经历与社区认知之间的脱节。促进因素包括专门为MICU量身定制的干预措施、护士之间团队合作和社会支持的优势,以及由于高离职率等因素而产生的变革愿望。参与者还强调了提供尽可能最佳护理的强烈动机以及通过相互支持来增强恢复力的愿望。
对障碍和促进因素的分析表明,通过针对特定科室的干预措施以及同伴支持和牧师等资源,改善医护人员处理道德伤害经历的机会具有价值。显然需要进行高层组织变革以满足我们护士的动态需求。