Aster Alexandra, Ragaller Sophia Viktoria, Raupach Tobias, Marx Ambra
Institute of Medical Education, University Hospital Bonn, Bonn, Germany.
Department of Psychosomatic Medicine and Psychotherapy, University Hospital Bonn, Bonn, Germany.
Med Sci Educ. 2025 Feb 27;35(3):1513-1522. doi: 10.1007/s40670-025-02342-7. eCollection 2025 Jun.
Virtual patients are already utilized in the teaching of medical history taking. Since its emergence, ChatGPT has been integrated into several areas of medical education. This study aimed to examine whether ChatGPT can be used to train empathic history taking while fostering students' subjective autonomy.
Third-year medical students took histories with ChatGPT 3.5 after entering a predefined prompt covering cardiological diseases. Afterwards, students answered a questionnaire regarding their experienced autonomy. All chats were analyzed using the Empathic Communication Coding System measuring ChatGPT's given empathic opportunities as well as students' responses.
Out of 659 interactions, 93 were identified as empathic. ChatGPT provided opportunities mostly through reporting emotional statements or challenges. Students sometimes missed reacting adequately to ChatGPT's opportunities but more often responded by implicit recognition of patient perspective and reported a high level of experienced autonomy.
The study yielded preliminary results that ChatGPT might be suitable as a tool mimicking a virtual patient while enabling an empathic history taking. To date, ChatGPT seems valid as a supplement to training with simulated patients. Medical faculty could consider integrating ChatGPT into teaching, such as through a flipped classroom approach, to guide students in its use as ChatGPT continues to gain attention.
虚拟患者已被用于病史采集教学。自ChatGPT出现以来,它已被整合到医学教育的多个领域。本研究旨在探讨ChatGPT是否可用于培养共情病史采集能力,同时促进学生的主观自主性。
三年级医学生在输入涵盖心脏病学疾病的预定义提示后,与ChatGPT 3.5进行病史采集。之后,学生回答了一份关于他们体验到的自主性的问卷。所有聊天记录均使用共情沟通编码系统进行分析,该系统用于衡量ChatGPT提供的共情机会以及学生的回答。
在659次互动中,有93次被确定为具有共情性。ChatGPT主要通过报告情感陈述或挑战来提供机会。学生有时会错过对ChatGPT提供的机会做出充分反应,但更多时候会通过隐含地认可患者的观点来做出回应,并报告体验到的自主性水平较高。
该研究产生了初步结果,即ChatGPT可能适合作为一种模仿虚拟患者的工具,同时实现共情病史采集。迄今为止,ChatGPT似乎可作为模拟患者培训的补充。随着ChatGPT持续受到关注,医学院教师可以考虑将其整合到教学中,例如通过翻转课堂的方式,指导学生使用。