Traylor Blaine, Fenner Emma, Western Adam, Seabold Brendan, Mool Allison, Schmid Jacob, Johnston Thomas, Robinson Dajonea, Kambhatla Akhila, Reddy Pruthvi Sainath, Thomas William, Merriman Tobias, Benedict Pickney, Tischkau Shelley, Torry Donald, Tobón Gabriel J, Selinfreund Richard
Mayo Clinic Hospital, Phoenix, AZ USA.
University of Tennessee, Memphis, TN USA.
Med Sci Educ. 2025 Mar 7;35(3):1537-1549. doi: 10.1007/s40670-025-02348-1. eCollection 2025 Jun.
The increasing complexity of medical education requires innovative tools to help students manage cognitive overload. Concept mapping (CM) enhances knowledge retention and integration by visually organizing information, and has received positive feedback in various educational contexts. However, the use of CM combined with interactive 3D courseware to teach the cellular mechanisms of bacterial sepsis is underexplored. This study evaluated the feasibility and effectiveness of integrating a 3D computer simulation with CM to improve understanding of sepsis. Fifty-two second-year medical students were randomized into three groups (A, B, and C). Each group completed five tasks: a pre-simulation self-assessment, a scaffolded pre-simulation CM, a computer simulation, a post-simulation CM, and a post-simulation self-assessment. Group A completed the tasks at the start of the sepsis case in the medical curriculum, Group B in the middle, and Group C at the end. A control group completed only the pre-simulation CM, and third-year students who had previously participated repeated the CM. Pre-simulation CM scores showed significant improvement in all three groups compared to the control group ( < 0.05). Post-simulation, Group C significantly outperformed Groups A and B ( < 0.05). Third-year students scored 15 points higher than Groups A and B ( < 0.001), but their scores were similar to Group C's. CM scores improved across all intervention groups, with Group C showing more than double the increase seen in Groups A and B. This study suggests that combining 3D simulations with CM is an effective strategy for teaching complex medical concepts and warrants further exploration of its long-term impact.
医学教育日益复杂,需要创新工具来帮助学生应对认知过载。概念图绘制(CM)通过直观地组织信息来增强知识的保留和整合,并在各种教育环境中获得了积极反馈。然而,将CM与交互式3D课件相结合用于教授细菌性脓毒症的细胞机制的研究尚少。本研究评估了将3D计算机模拟与CM相结合以提高对脓毒症理解的可行性和有效性。52名二年级医学生被随机分为三组(A、B和C)。每组完成五项任务:模拟前自我评估、有支架的模拟前CM、计算机模拟、模拟后CM和模拟后自我评估。A组在医学课程中脓毒症病例开始时完成任务,B组在中间阶段完成,C组在结束时完成。一个对照组只完成模拟前CM,之前参与过的三年级学生重复进行CM。与对照组相比,所有三组的模拟前CM分数均有显著提高(<0.05)。模拟后,C组明显优于A组和B组(<0.05)。三年级学生的得分比A组和B组高15分(<0.001),但他们的分数与C组相似。所有干预组的CM分数均有所提高,C组的提高幅度是A组和B组的两倍多。本研究表明,将3D模拟与CM相结合是教授复杂医学概念的有效策略,值得进一步探索其长期影响。