Masood Zubia, Jawaid Masood, Aly Syed Moyn, Muhammad Zubair
Zubia Masood, MBBS, FCPS (Surgery), MHPE. Associate Professor of Surgery, Baqai Medical University, Karachi Pakistan.
Masood Jawaid, MBBS, MCPS, FCPS (Surgery), MHPE Director Medical Affairs, PharmEvo.
Pak J Med Sci. 2024 Nov;40(10):2305-2308. doi: 10.12669/pjms.40.10.10526.
Concept Maps (CM) aid in the acquisition of new information, and comprehend prior knowledge with better retention. Their use is not explored in undergraduate surgical education in our country, hence this study aimed to compare the surgery test scores of undergraduate medical students taught by concept maps and interactive lectures.
This quasi-experimental study was carried out at the Department of Surgery, at a Private University Hospital among 60 students of fourth year MBBS from 2017-2018. The students were divided into Group-A taught by interactive lectures and Group-B taught by CM. Post class Multiple Choice Questions test was taken and scores were compared for immediate effects on knowledge and short term knowledge retention using the Unpaired t- test. A P-value of < 0.05 was considered significant.
Our study reported a mean test score of 19.5 (2.75 ± 0.49) for the Group-A, while 21.1 (3.49 ± 0.65) for Group-B with a negative t value of 2.003 with a significant p-value of 0.05. This showed that the test scores of Group-A were lower than the scores of Group-B.
Concept Maps is an effective and promising way to give learners better understanding of complex concepts in short amounts of time. providing valuable evidence for instituting the use of concept maps as a continuous teaching strategy for medical students.
概念图(CM)有助于获取新信息,并能更好地理解和保留先前知识。我国本科外科教育中尚未探索其应用,因此本研究旨在比较通过概念图教学和互动讲座教学的本科医学生的外科考试成绩。
本准实验研究在一所私立大学医院的外科进行,研究对象为2017 - 2018年60名四年制医学学士课程的四年级学生。学生被分为A组(通过互动讲座教学)和B组(通过概念图教学)。课程结束后进行了多项选择题测试,并使用非配对t检验比较成绩,以评估对知识的即时影响和短期知识保留情况。P值<0.05被认为具有统计学意义。
我们的研究报告显示,A组的平均考试成绩为19.5(2.75±0.49),而B组为21.1(3.49±0.65),t值为 - 2.003,p值为0.05,具有统计学意义。这表明A组的考试成绩低于B组。
概念图是一种有效且有前景的方法,能让学习者在短时间内更好地理解复杂概念,为将概念图作为医学生的持续教学策略提供了有价值的证据。