Oyeniji Oluyinka, Wakunuma Kutoma, Owoseni Adebowale
Center for Computing and Social Responsibility, De Montfort University, Leicester, United Kingdom.
IBRO Neurosci Rep. 2025 Jun 18;19:174-191. doi: 10.1016/j.ibneur.2025.06.002. eCollection 2025 Dec.
The global neuroethics discourse has gained prominence since the beginning of the 21st century. Perspectives on neuroethics have been drawn from USA, Asia, the European Union etc. In Africa, the discourse has been largely influenced by neurogenomics research and collaborations across countries in the region. As neuroethicists continue to propose considerations for framing neuroethics discourse in Africa, ethical issues arise from not only largescale neurogenomics research, but such other neuroscience and brain research projects conducted in heterogeneous societies on the continent. Such neuroscience research projects carried out in academic institutions and medical facilities are yet to be subjected to an investigation of ethical issues arising therefrom. This paper therefore took a departure from neuroethics discourse being shaped in neurogenomics and international collaborations to consider what ethical issues arise from neuroscience broadly across parts of Africa. We conducted a scoping review of neuroscience research and neuroethics publications, complemented by the snowballing method to investigate ethical issues arising from such research endeavors. The research was grounded in ubuntu principles as lens through which ethical, legal and social implications of African neuroscience research were viewed. Findings established ethical issues peculiar within the African neuroscience research context including inequitable access to neuroscience research, distrust, lack of research funding, imposition of foreign methods without standardisation within contexts, violence and use of restraints, threat to life and morbidity, etc as ethical issues of neuroscience in Africa.
自21世纪初以来,全球神经伦理学讨论日益突出。神经伦理学的观点来自美国、亚洲、欧盟等。在非洲,该讨论很大程度上受到神经基因组学研究以及该地区各国之间合作的影响。随着神经伦理学家继续提出在非洲构建神经伦理学讨论的考量因素,伦理问题不仅源于大规模神经基因组学研究,还源于在非洲大陆不同社会开展的其他神经科学和大脑研究项目。在学术机构和医疗设施中开展的此类神经科学研究项目尚未对由此产生的伦理问题进行调查。因此,本文背离了在神经基因组学和国际合作中形成的神经伦理学讨论,转而思考非洲各地广泛的神经科学会引发哪些伦理问题。我们对神经科学研究和神经伦理学出版物进行了范围界定审查,并辅以滚雪球法来调查此类研究工作引发的伦理问题。该研究以乌班图原则为基础,以此为视角审视非洲神经科学研究的伦理、法律和社会影响。研究结果确定了非洲神经科学研究背景下特有的伦理问题,包括神经科学研究的获取机会不平等、不信任、缺乏研究资金、在不同背景下未经标准化就采用外国方法、暴力和使用约束措施、对生命和发病率的威胁等,这些都是非洲神经科学的伦理问题。