Kazmierczak-Murray Sylwia, Kenny Neil, Carolan Suzanne, Doyle Alison
Institute of Education, Dublin City University, Ireland.
Louth Primary Care, Health Service Executive, Ireland.
PLoS One. 2025 Jul 11;20(7):e0327373. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0327373. eCollection 2025.
Developmental Language Disorder (DLD) affects around 7% of children globally, yet the scholarship on it is significantly underdeveloped. Emerging research suggests that DLD is both underdiagnosed by clinicians and misunderstood by parents. This study explores the perspectives of both clinicians and parents regarding their experiences of the process of giving and receiving a DLD diagnosis in the Republic of Ireland. Semi-structured qualitative group interviews were conducted with 15 parents and seven clinicians. The data were analysed using a reflexive, thematic analysis. Four themes were identified: "challenges of giving a DLD diagnosis", "communicating a DLD diagnosis", "utility of DLD diagnosis for children and families" and "going forward and recommendations". Clinicians reported systemic barriers in the healthcare system, including limited therapy time, long waitlists, and staff turnover, as major challenges in diagnosing DLD. Many expressed a lack of confidence in providing a diagnosis without multidisciplinary support which would support them in 'ruling out' other neurodevelopmental differences. Communicating the diagnosis was often inconsistent, with many parents feeling unsupported and uninformed about the nature and impact of DLD. Parents felt inadequate at being left with communicating the diagnosis of DLD and its impact to their children. The participants emphasised urgent need for greater awareness, teacher and clinical education, post-diagnosis support, and increased national advocacy in relation to DLD in Ireland. Both clinicians and parents saw DLD diagnosis as essential for accessing therapeutic and educational support, yet it was the access to these supports that seemed to influence the diagnostic decisions. Importantly, our research documents clinicians' fear of getting the "right" condition for diagnosis, which may be firstly at odds with the individual profiles of children, and secondly, acts as a barrier in accessing the needed support. In light of growing awareness of the co-occurrence of neurodevelopmental differences, we call for enhanced support for clinicians to build their confidence in navigating the evolving diagnostic criteria of DLD.
发育性语言障碍(DLD)在全球约7%的儿童中存在,但对此的学术研究仍极不发达。新兴研究表明,DLD在临床诊断中未得到充分诊断,且被家长误解。本研究探讨了爱尔兰共和国临床医生和家长对于给出和接受DLD诊断过程的看法。对15名家长和7名临床医生进行了半结构化定性小组访谈。使用反思性主题分析法对数据进行了分析。确定了四个主题:“给出DLD诊断的挑战”、“传达DLD诊断”、“DLD诊断对儿童和家庭的效用”以及“未来发展与建议”。临床医生报告称,医疗系统存在系统性障碍,包括治疗时间有限、候诊名单长和人员流动,这些是诊断DLD的主要挑战。许多人表示,在没有多学科支持的情况下进行诊断缺乏信心,而多学科支持可以帮助他们“排除”其他神经发育差异。传达诊断结果往往不一致,许多家长感到在DLD的性质和影响方面没有得到支持且信息不足。家长们觉得自己在向孩子传达DLD诊断及其影响方面能力不足。参与者强调,爱尔兰迫切需要提高认识、开展教师和临床教育、提供诊断后支持,并加强全国范围内对DLD的宣传。临床医生和家长都认为DLD诊断对于获得治疗和教育支持至关重要,但正是获得这些支持的情况似乎影响了诊断决策。重要的是,我们的研究记录了临床医生担心做出“正确”的诊断,这首先可能与儿童的个体情况不符,其次,这成为获得所需支持的障碍。鉴于对神经发育差异共现的认识不断提高,我们呼吁加强对临床医生的支持,以增强他们在应对不断演变的DLD诊断标准方面的信心。