Celik Nazmiye, Sarmasoglu Kilikcier Senay, Tasdelen Teker Gulsen, Keskin Gulsen, Akın Mine, Ozmert Sengul, Elcin Melih, Senel Emrah
Medical Education and Informatics, Hacettepe University Faculty of Medicine, Ankara, Turkey
Anesthesiology and Reanimation, Ministry of Health Ankara Bilkent City Hospital, Ankara, Turkey.
BMJ Open Qual. 2025 Jul 13;14(3):e003249. doi: 10.1136/bmjoq-2024-003249.
The Anaesthesiologists' Non-Technical Skills in Denmark Form (ANTSdk) is a widely accepted, practical, and comprehensive measurement tool used by anaesthesiologists and other healthcare professionals. This study aims to adapt the ANTSdk into Turkish as a valid and reliable assessment instrument. By doing so, it will contribute to establishing a common language and standardised terminology for integrating non-technical skills into the Turkish healthcare system.
We conducted a standardised cross-cultural adaptation process. The psychometric properties of the Turkish-adapted version of the ANTSdk were evaluated through observations of 81 real paediatric surgical operating room teams, assessed simultaneously by two independent observers. Validity was examined using content validity analysis and confirmatory factor analysis. Internal consistency and inter-rater reliability of the Turkish version of ANTSdk (ANTStr) were also assessed.
The specified factorial model retained the same grouping of elements into four domains as in the original version of ANTSdk. All standardised factor loadings were greater than 0.3. The inter-rater reliability, measured by the intraclass correlation coefficient of the global score, was 0.98. The Cronbach's alpha coefficient for the scores provided by the first rater ranged from 0.83 to 0.94, while for the second rater, it ranged from 0.84 to 0.94. The generalisability coefficient calculated for ANTStr was exceptionally high at 0.96.
The Turkish version of ANTSdk demonstrates strong psychometric properties for evaluating paediatric surgical team performance in the operating room. This translated instrument can be used to assess non-technical skills in paediatric surgical teams within real clinical settings, facilitating benchmarking and international collaboration.
丹麦麻醉医生非技术技能量表(ANTSdk)是一种被麻醉医生和其他医疗专业人员广泛接受、实用且全面的测量工具。本研究旨在将ANTSdk改编为土耳其语版本,作为一种有效且可靠的评估工具。这样做将有助于建立一种通用语言和标准化术语,以便将非技术技能融入土耳其医疗系统。
我们进行了标准化的跨文化改编过程。通过对81个真实的小儿外科手术室团队进行观察,由两名独立观察者同时进行评估,来评价ANTSdk土耳其改编版的心理测量特性。使用内容效度分析和验证性因素分析来检验效度。还评估了ANTSdk土耳其语版本(ANTStr)的内部一致性和评分者间信度。
指定的因子模型保留了与ANTSdk原始版本相同的四个领域的元素分组。所有标准化因子载荷均大于0.3。通过整体评分的组内相关系数测量的评分者间信度为0.98。第一位评分者提供的分数的克朗巴哈α系数范围为0.83至0.94,而第二位评分者的范围为0.84至0.94。为ANTStr计算的概化系数异常高,为0.96。
ANTSdk土耳其语版本在评估小儿外科团队在手术室中的表现方面显示出强大的心理测量特性。这种翻译后的工具可用于在实际临床环境中评估小儿外科团队的非技术技能,有助于进行基准比较和国际合作。