Özkan Feyza Nur, Verlaan Martin, Muis Sanne, Zijl Firmijn
Delft Institute of Applied Mathematics, Delft University of Technology, Mekelweg 4, 2628 CD Delft, The Netherlands.
Hydrodynamics and Forecasting, Deltares, P.O. Box 177, 2600 MH Delft, The Netherlands.
Ocean Dyn. 2025;75(8):66. doi: 10.1007/s10236-025-01713-3. Epub 2025 Jul 19.
Accurate storm surge modeling is essential for predicting coastal flooding and mitigating impacts on vulnerable regions. This study evaluates the influence of different sea surface drag parameterizations on surge predictions using the Global Tide and Surge Model (GTSM) over a 10-year period (2006-2015) and two storm events. Four model experiments were tested, ranging from a fully dynamic formulation, including variable air density, atmospheric stability, and sea-state-dependent drag, to a simplified constant-drag approach. Results show that advanced drag formulations reduced the underestimation of annual maximum surge values from 18% to 12% globally, with the variable Charnock parameter contributing the most. Conversely, using a constant Charnock value and thereby neglecting wave-dependent roughness increases prediction errors, especially in regions with highly variable sea states. Case studies of Storm Xaver (2013) and Hurricane Fiona (2022) show that advanced parameterizations better capture wind stress variations, reducing root mean square error from 0.21 m to 0.16 m for Xaver and improving surge predictions by up to 0.30 m for Fiona. Consistent with earlier studies, a persistent underestimation of extreme surge events remains across all experiments. While wave-dependent roughness improves performance, no single parameter fully explains this bias. However, wave-dependent roughness particularly enhances model performance in high-latitude and storm-prone areas, where sea state and atmospheric conditions vary widely. Our results show that variations in air density and atmospheric stability have minimal impact on surge height. As such, prioritizing the implementation of dynamic, sea-state-dependent drag formulations, particularly variable Charnock, is key to further improving the accuracy of storm surge forecasting systems and future projections.
准确的风暴潮建模对于预测沿海洪水和减轻对脆弱地区的影响至关重要。本研究使用全球潮汐和风暴潮模型(GTSM)在10年期间(2006 - 2015年)和两次风暴事件中评估了不同海面阻力参数化对风暴潮预测的影响。测试了四个模型实验,从包括可变空气密度、大气稳定性和海况依赖阻力的完全动态公式,到简化的恒定阻力方法。结果表明,先进的阻力公式将全球年度最大风暴潮值的低估从18%降低到了12%,其中可变查诺克参数贡献最大。相反,使用恒定的查诺克值从而忽略与波浪相关的粗糙度会增加预测误差,特别是在海况变化很大的地区。风暴“哈韦尔”(2013年)和飓风“菲奥娜”(2022年)的案例研究表明,先进的参数化能更好地捕捉风应力变化,将“哈韦尔”的均方根误差从0.21米降低到0.16米,并将“菲奥娜”的风暴潮预测提高了多达0.30米。与早期研究一致,所有实验中对极端风暴潮事件的持续低估仍然存在。虽然与波浪相关的粗糙度提高了性能,但没有一个参数能完全解释这种偏差。然而,与波浪相关的粗糙度尤其能提高高纬度和风暴多发地区的模型性能,在这些地区海况和大气条件差异很大。我们的结果表明,空气密度和大气稳定性的变化对风暴潮高度的影响最小。因此,优先实施动态的、海况依赖的阻力公式,特别是可变查诺克公式,是进一步提高风暴潮预报系统准确性和未来预测的关键。