Cox J D, Stoffel T J
Cancer. 1977 Jul;40(1):156-60. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(197707)40:1<156::aid-cncr2820400126>3.0.co;2-#.
The presence of malignant cells in needle biopsy specimens following irradiation for adenocarcinoma of the prostate has been used to criticize or defend this treatment. At Walter Reed Medical Center, 38 consecutive patients with Stage Cadenocarcinoma underwent definitive irradiation between August 1970 and March 1973. The median dose to the pelvis was 7000 rads in 31 fractions in 43 days (2030 ret). Post treatment examination included palpation of the prostate and transperineal biopsy of the most suspicious areas. Gradual disappearance of the palpable tumor occurred in all patients. Two men have had clinical evidence of re-growth of prostatic cancer. Thirty-three patients have had up to seven biopsies each for a total of 139, an average of four biopsies per patient. There were 49 positive and 90 negative biopsies. Positive biopsy rate correlated only with the interval after irradiation--60% at six months, 37% at one year, 30% at 18 months, and approximately 19% after two and one-half years. There was no correlation of biopsy results with pre-irradiation estrogen or orchiectomy, with time-dose-fractionation relationships, or with prognosis. These biopsies provide interesting data about the regression rate of prostatic adenocarcinoma, but they have no significance for the individual patient. They have, therefore, been eliminated from follow-up studies.
前列腺腺癌放疗后针吸活检标本中恶性细胞的存在曾被用于批评或捍卫这种治疗方法。在沃尔特里德医疗中心,1970年8月至1973年3月期间,38例连续的C期腺癌患者接受了根治性放疗。骨盆的中位剂量为7000拉德,分31次在43天内给予(2030伦琴)。治疗后检查包括前列腺触诊和对最可疑区域进行经会阴活检。所有患者可触及的肿瘤均逐渐消失。有两名男性出现前列腺癌复发的临床证据。33例患者每人最多接受了7次活检,共计139次,平均每人4次活检。活检结果为阳性的有49次,阴性的有90次。阳性活检率仅与放疗后的时间间隔相关——6个月时为60%,1年时为37%,18个月时为30%,两年半后约为19%。活检结果与放疗前的雌激素或睾丸切除术、时间-剂量-分割关系或预后均无相关性。这些活检提供了有关前列腺腺癌消退率的有趣数据,但对个体患者并无意义。因此,它们已被排除在随访研究之外。