Slinger Peter, Omar Maram, Younus Sarah, Charow Rebecca, Baxter Michael, Campbell Craig, Giuliani Meredith, Goldmacher Jesse, Jeyakumar Tharshini, Karsan Inaara, Papadakos Janet, Papadakos Tina, Rotstein Alexandra Jane, Yee May-Sann, Siddiqui Asad, Restrepo Marcos Silva, Zhang Melody, Wiljer David
University Health Network, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Temerty School of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
JMIR Med Educ. 2025 Jul 23;11:e69443. doi: 10.2196/69443.
Many national medical governing bodies encourage physicians to engage in continuing professional development (CPD) activities to cultivate their knowledge and skills to ensure their clinical practice reflects the current standards and evidence base. However, physicians often encounter various barriers that hinder their participation in CPD programs, such as time constraints, a lack of centralized coordination, and limited opportunities for self-assessment. The literature has highlighted the strength of using question-based learning interventions to augment physician learning and further enable change in practice. CPD By the Minute (CPD-Min) is a smartphone-enabled web-based app that was developed to address self-assessment gaps and barriers to engagement in CPD activities.
This study aimed to assess the app using four objectives: (1) engagement and use of the app throughout the study, (2) effectiveness of this tool as a CPD activity, (3) relevance of the disseminated information to physicians' practice, and (4) acceptability to physicians of this novel tool as an educational initiative.
The CPD-Min app disseminated 2 multiple-choice questions (1-min each) each week with feedback and references. Participants included licensed staff physicians, fellows, and residents across Canada. A concurrent multimethods study was conducted, consisting of preintervention and postintervention surveys, semistructured interviews, and app analytics. Guided by the Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, and Maintenance framework, the qualitative data were analyzed deductively and inductively.
Of the 105 Canadian anesthesiologists participating in the study, 89 (84.8%) were staff physicians, 12 (11.4%) were fellows, and 4 (3.8%) were residents. Participants completed 110 questions each over the course of 52 weeks, with an average completion rate of 75% (SD 33%). In total, 40.9% (43/105) of participants answered >90% of the questions, including 15.2% (16/105) who completed all questions. Moreover, 69% (52/75) of participants reported the app to be an effective and valuable resource for their practice and to enhance continuous learning. Most participants (63/75, 84%) who completed the postsurveys reported that they would likely continue using the app as a CPD tool. These findings were further supported by the interview data. Three key themes were identified: the practical design of the novel educational app facilitates its adoption by clinicians, the app was perceived as a useful knowledge tool for continuous learning, and the app's low-stakes testing environment cultivated independent learning attitudes.
The findings suggest the potential of the app to improve longitudinal assessments that promote lifelong learning among clinicians. The positive feedback and increased acceptance of the app supports it as an innovative tool for knowledge retention and CPD. Future research efforts should prioritize evaluating the app's long-term sustainability and its impact on physicians' practice, as well as exploring alternative approaches (such as artificial intelligence-based tools) for generating questions.
许多国家医学管理机构鼓励医生参与持续专业发展(CPD)活动,以培养他们的知识和技能,确保他们的临床实践反映当前的标准和证据基础。然而,医生经常遇到各种阻碍他们参与CPD项目的障碍,如时间限制、缺乏集中协调以及自我评估机会有限。文献强调了使用基于问题的学习干预措施来增强医生学习并进一步推动实践变革的优势。“每分钟CPD”(CPD-Min)是一款基于网络的智能手机应用程序,旨在解决自我评估差距以及参与CPD活动的障碍。
本研究旨在通过四个目标评估该应用程序:(1)在整个研究过程中应用程序的参与度和使用情况;(2)该工具作为CPD活动的有效性;(3)所传播信息与医生实践的相关性;(4)医生对这种新型工具作为教育举措的接受度。
CPD-Min应用程序每周发布2个多项选择题(每题1分钟),并提供反馈和参考文献。参与者包括加拿大各地的持牌在职医生、研究员和住院医师。进行了一项同步多方法研究,包括干预前和干预后调查、半结构化访谈以及应用程序分析。在“覆盖范围、有效性、采用率、实施和维持”框架的指导下,对定性数据进行了演绎和归纳分析。
参与该研究的105名加拿大麻醉医生中,89名(84.8%)是在职医生,12名(11.4%)是研究员,4名(3.8%)是住院医师。参与者在52周内每人完成了110道题,平均完成率为75%(标准差33%)。总共有40.9%(43/105)的参与者回答了超过90%的问题,其中15.2%(16/105)完成了所有问题。此外,69%(52/75)的参与者报告该应用程序对他们的实践是一种有效且有价值的资源,并能促进持续学习。完成调查后的大多数参与者(63/75,84%)表示他们可能会继续将该应用程序用作CPD工具。访谈数据进一步支持了这些发现。确定了三个关键主题:新型教育应用程序的实用设计便于临床医生采用;该应用程序被视为持续学习的有用知识工具;该应用程序的低风险测试环境培养了自主学习态度。
研究结果表明该应用程序有潜力改善纵向评估,促进临床医生的终身学习。对该应用程序的积极反馈和更高接受度支持其作为知识保留和CPD的创新工具。未来的研究应优先评估该应用程序的长期可持续性及其对医生实践的影响,以及探索生成问题的替代方法(如基于人工智能的工具)。