Constraints in temperature adaptation reinforce differences in thermal niche between mesophilic and psychrotolerant group species.

Experimental evolution has demonstrated that mesophilic microbes readily adapt to increases in temperature. However, many microbes are psychrotolerant and resistant to cold, which is associated with physiological specializations, suggesting constraints in thermal adaptation. We hypothesized that constraints would limit adaption differently in a mesophilic species () compared with its psychrotolerant relative -with adaptation at cooler temperatures and adaptation at higher temperatures being constrained in each species, respectively. To test this hypothesis, we imposed 140 generations of selection at temperatures at and below the optimum for productivity for both species. The fitness and thermal performance of evolved bacteria showed ancestral thermal niche plays a role in thermal adaptation over this time scale, in support of our hypothesis of adaptive constraints. Temperature-dependent trade-offs appeared common in , with fitness gains associated with decreases in operational niche width; fitness gains at one temperature caused a decrease in the range of temperatures that the bacterium showed appreciable growth. Genome resequencing showed that variation in mutation supply and selection strength could not explain temperature-dependent responses to selection. Importantly, metabolic theory only held true for mesophilic showing abundant but less studied psychrotolerant species could follow different adaptive trajectories.