Castellani Rudolph J, Kostelecky Nicolas, Ahrendsen Jared T, Nassan Malik, Jamshidi Pouya, Iverson Grant L
Department of Pathology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL 60611, USA.
Department of Pathology, Western Michigan University Homer Stryker M.D. School of Medicine, Kalamazoo, MI 49007, USA.
Brain Sci. 2025 Jul 8;15(7):729. doi: 10.3390/brainsci15070729.
: There are no validated clinical diagnostic criteria for chronic traumatic encephalopathy or traumatic encephalopathy syndrome (TES). To understand the historical clinical condition, its applicability to modern day athletes, and the pathogenesis of clinical problems, we examined the literature describing boxers from the 20th century, with specific attention paid to neurological findings and characteristics of clinical disease progression. : Data were extracted for 243 boxers included in 45 articles published between 1928 and 1999, including cases from articles originally published in German. The presence or absence of 22 neurological signs and features were extracted. : The most common neurological problems were slurring dysarthria (49%), gait disturbances (44%), and memory loss (36%), with several other problems that were less frequent, including hyperreflexia (25%), ataxia (22%), increased tone (19%), and extensor Babinski sign (16%). Frank dementia appeared in some cases (17%). There were significantly fewer neurological deficits reported in boxers who fought in the latter part of the 20th century compared to boxers who fought earlier in the century. For more than half of the cases, there were no comments about whether the neurological problems were progressive (145, 60%). A progressive condition was described in 71 cases (29%) and a stationary or improving condition was described in 27 cases (11%). Canonical neurodegenerative disease-like progression was described in 15 cases (6%). : Neurological problems associated with boxing-related neurotrauma during the 20th century are the foundation for present-day TES. However, the clinical signs and features in the 20th century differ in most ways from the modern criteria for TES.
目前尚无针对慢性创伤性脑病或创伤性脑病综合征(TES)的有效临床诊断标准。为了解其历史临床状况、在现代运动员中的适用性以及临床问题的发病机制,我们查阅了描述20世纪拳击手的文献,特别关注神经学检查结果和临床疾病进展特征。
从1928年至1999年发表的45篇文章中纳入的243名拳击手提取数据,包括最初以德文发表的文章中的病例。提取了22种神经体征和特征的有无情况。
最常见的神经问题是构音障碍(49%)、步态障碍(44%)和记忆丧失(36%),还有其他一些不太常见的问题,包括反射亢进(25%)、共济失调(22%)、肌张力增加(19%)和巴宾斯基征阳性(16%)。部分病例出现明显痴呆(17%)。与20世纪早期参赛的拳击手相比,20世纪后期参赛的拳击手报告的神经功能缺损明显较少。超过半数的病例(145例,60%)未提及神经问题是否呈进行性。71例(29%)描述为病情进行性发展,27例(11%)描述为病情静止或好转。15例(6%)描述为典型的神经退行性疾病样进展。
20世纪与拳击相关神经创伤有关的神经问题是当今创伤性脑病综合征的基础。然而,20世纪的临床体征和特征在大多数方面与现代创伤性脑病综合征的标准不同。