Zanin Luca, Broglio Laura, Panciani Pier Paolo, Bergomi Riccardo, De Rosa Giorgia, Ricciardi Luca, Guzzi Giusy, Fiorindi Alessandro, Brembilla Carlo, Restelli Francesco, Costa Francesco, Montemurro Nicola, Fontanella Marco Maria
Unit of Neurosurgery, ASST Spedali Civili di Brescia, 25123 Brescia, Italy.
Unit of Neurophysiopathology, ASST Spedali Civili di Bresciadi Brescia, 25123 Brescia, Italy.
Brain Sci. 2025 Jul 19;15(7):768. doi: 10.3390/brainsci15070768.
Intraoperative neurophysiological monitoring (IONM) is increasingly used during spinal surgery to reduce the risk of neurological complications. This systematic review evaluates both the clinical outcomes and cost-effectiveness of IONM in contemporary spinal surgery. A comprehensive literature search was conducted to identify studies evaluating IONM in spinal surgery. Twenty-three studies were included: twenty-one reporting clinical outcomes and two focusing on economic analysis. Data on neurological deficits, monitoring accuracy, and cost-effectiveness were extracted and analyzed. Analysis of the included studies showed that IONM reduced the risk of neurological deficits across various types of spinal surgery. The diagnostic accuracy varied by modality, with MEP showing the highest sensitivity (90.2%) and SSEP demonstrating high specificity (97.1%). The greatest benefit was observed in deformity surgery and spinal tumors. D-wave monitoring showed efficacy for intramedullary tumors. Economic analysis demonstrated that IONM is cost-effective when the neurological complication rate exceeds 0.3%, with potential savings of over USD 23,000 per case. IONM significantly improves neurological outcomes in spinal surgery and is cost-effective in most clinical scenarios, particularly in high-risk procedures. Multimodal monitoring approaches provide the most comprehensive neurological assessment. These findings support the routine use of IONM in contemporary spinal surgery, especially for complex cases.
术中神经生理监测(IONM)在脊柱手术中的应用日益广泛,以降低神经并发症的风险。本系统评价评估了IONM在当代脊柱手术中的临床结局和成本效益。进行了全面的文献检索,以确定评估IONM在脊柱手术中应用的研究。纳入了23项研究:21项报告了临床结局,2项侧重于经济分析。提取并分析了有关神经功能缺损、监测准确性和成本效益的数据。对纳入研究的分析表明,IONM降低了各种类型脊柱手术中神经功能缺损的风险。诊断准确性因监测方式而异,运动诱发电位(MEP)显示出最高的敏感性(90.2%),体感诱发电位(SSEP)显示出高特异性(97.1%)。在脊柱畸形手术和脊柱肿瘤手术中观察到最大益处。D波监测对髓内肿瘤显示出疗效。经济分析表明,当神经并发症发生率超过0.3%时,IONM具有成本效益,每例潜在节省超过23000美元。IONM显著改善了脊柱手术中的神经结局,并且在大多数临床情况下具有成本效益,特别是在高风险手术中。多模式监测方法提供了最全面的神经评估。这些发现支持在当代脊柱手术中常规使用IONM,尤其是对于复杂病例。