Dubina Andrew G, Dunham Alexandra M, Conroy Julia L, Funk Karli M, Jauregui Julio J, Sponseller Paul D, Abzug Joshua M
Department of Orthopaedics, University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD 21201, USA.
Department of Orthopaedics, Johns Hopkins Children's Center, Baltimore, MD 21287, USA.
Children (Basel). 2025 Jul 11;12(7):923. doi: 10.3390/children12070923.
: Timing of fixation of stable slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE) is controversial. As pressure mounts to limit inpatient admissions and procedures, our aim was to investigate whether treatment of SCFE in a delayed manner is a safe alternative to immediate fixation. Our hypothesis was that there would be no difference in complications for stable slips treated immediately (<24 h) versus semi-electively (>24 h) with screw fixation. : A retrospective review was performed at two academic institutions during a 10-year-period yielding 91 SCFEs. Data collected included patient demographics, time to treatment, radiographic measurements (Southwick angle), and complications. Between-group analysis was performed using Welch's -test and Fisher's exact test. : 91 stable SCFEs were identified with a median age of 12.3 years (IQR: 11.4-13.3). A total of 62 (68%) slips were treated immediately while 29 (32%) were treated in a semi-elective manner with a median time from diagnosis to surgery of 4 days (range: 2-11 days). There were no instances of >18° increase in Southwick angle in either group or conversion from stable to unstable slips during the semi-elective period. Overall, 12 (13%) patients experienced complications, but no difference in complication rate was observed between groups (15% vs. 10%, = 0.75). However, the complication profile varied between groups. Of note, two patients (2%, 2/91) experienced AVN, both of which were treated in a semi-elective manner and underwent in situ pinning. : There was no difference in complication rate between stable SCFEs treated immediately or semi-electively; however, the complication profile differed by group. No SCFEs in either group had >18° worsening of the Southwick angle between the time of diagnosis and the time of fixation and there were no conversions of stables slips to unstable slips while waiting for semi-elective surgery. These findings suggest that performing semi-elective surgical fixation within 11 days of diagnosing stable, mild SCFEs appears to be a safe alternative to inpatient admission at the time of diagnosis.
稳定型股骨头骨骺滑脱(SCFE)的固定时机存在争议。由于限制住院人数和手术的压力不断增加,我们的目的是研究延迟治疗SCFE是否是立即固定的安全替代方案。我们的假设是,对于稳定型滑脱,立即治疗(<24小时)与半择期治疗(>24小时)采用螺钉固定的并发症发生率没有差异。:在两家学术机构进行了为期10年的回顾性研究,共纳入91例SCFE患者。收集的数据包括患者人口统计学资料、治疗时间、影像学测量(Southwick角)和并发症情况。组间分析采用Welch's t检验和Fisher精确检验。:共识别出91例稳定型SCFE患者,中位年龄为12.3岁(四分位间距:11.4 - 13.3岁)。其中62例(68%)滑脱患者立即接受治疗,29例(32%)接受半择期治疗,从诊断到手术的中位时间为4天(范围:2 - 11天)。两组中均未出现Southwick角增加>18°的情况,且在半择期治疗期间未出现从稳定型滑脱转变为不稳定型滑脱的情况。总体而言,12例(13%)患者出现并发症,但两组之间并发症发生率无差异(15%对10%,P = 0.75)。然而,两组的并发症类型有所不同。值得注意的是,2例患者(2%,2/91)发生了股骨头缺血性坏死(AVN),均接受了半择期治疗并进行了原位克氏针固定。:立即治疗或半择期治疗稳定型SCFE的并发症发生率没有差异;然而,两组的并发症类型不同。两组中在诊断至固定期间,均没有SCFE患者的Southwick角恶化>18°,且在等待半择期手术期间没有稳定型滑脱转变为不稳定型滑脱的情况。这些发现表明,对于诊断为稳定、轻度SCFE的患者,在诊断后11天内进行半择期手术固定似乎是一种安全的替代方案,可避免在诊断时住院治疗。