Lenkei Rita, Pérez Fraga Paula, Zsiros László Róbert, Szigeti Balázs, Faragó Tamás
BARKS Lab, Department of Ethology, Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary.
Biol Futur. 2025 Jun;76(2):273-291. doi: 10.1007/s42977-025-00276-0. Epub 2025 Jul 29.
The concept of a "talking" dog has long fascinated humans, as presented throughout history in pieces of folklore, literature, and other fields of culture. While speech, as we know, is a uniquely human trait, the evolution of dogs in close proximity to humans has allowed them to develop strategies that facilitate heterospecific communication with us. In this work, we explore the scientific plausibility of enhancing canine vocalisation towards speech-like communication, as Csányi (Bukfenc és Jeromos: hogyan gondolkodnak a kutyák? Vince K, 2001) suggested. Our approach involves a comprehensive overview of the anatomical, cognitive, and evolutionary features of dogs that may relate to speech, as well as describing their role in popular culture and examining novel technological aspects. We also provide an outlook on hypothetical possibilities of a "talking" dog and its possible implications. We conclude that while dogs have acquired remarkable human-directed social and communicative skills, the feasibility and desirability of spoken language in dogs remain questionable. Instead, understanding canine vocal and non-vocal communication within the context of human-animal interaction provides valuable insights into both language evolution and the mechanisms underpinning interspecies cooperation, also providing practical tools for the novel field of ethorobotics.
“会说话”的狗这一概念长期以来一直吸引着人类,在历史上的民间故事、文学作品以及其他文化领域中均有体现。我们知道,言语是人类独有的特征,但狗在与人类的长期亲近过程中不断进化,发展出了一些有助于与人类进行跨物种交流的策略。在这项研究中,我们探讨了按照察伊(《布克芬茨与杰罗莫斯:狗如何思考?》,文斯·K,2001年)的建议,增强犬类发声以实现类似言语交流的科学合理性。我们的方法包括全面概述狗在解剖学、认知和进化方面可能与言语相关的特征,描述它们在流行文化中的作用,并研究新的技术层面。我们还展望了“会说话”的狗的假设可能性及其可能产生的影响。我们的结论是,虽然狗已经获得了显著的面向人类的社交和沟通技能,但狗掌握口语的可行性和可取性仍然存疑。相反,在人 - 动物互动的背景下理解犬类的有声和无声交流,能为语言进化以及跨物种合作的基础机制提供有价值的见解,也为动物行为机器人学这一新兴领域提供实用工具。